Denis Villeneuve Announced as Bond 26 Director

1789101113»

Comments

  • Posts: 2,260
    M was actually supposed to be a twist-villain in Spectre, but Fiennes convinced them not to do such thing.

    It would make sense, who would hire Bond after M died?
  • SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷ Lekki, Lagos, Nigeria
    Posts: 2,803
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.
  • LeonardPineLeonardPine The Bar on the Beach
    Posts: 4,440
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...
  • Posts: 15,927
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    From what I remember, some did express skepticism, but for whatever reason they decided to go ahead with it.
  • SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷ Lekki, Lagos, Nigeria
    edited July 28 Posts: 2,803
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    Ok. But I think Amy Pascal was against that. Or maybe I didn't read it correctly or can't fully remember.
  • Posts: 2,310
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    Ok. But I think Amy Pascal was against that. Or maybe I didn't read it correctly or can't fully remember.

    All the leaks relating to Spectre from the time are on:

    https://bleedingcool.com/movies/when-blofeld-was-a-woman-in-spectre-sony-leaks/

    Makes for a super interesting read.

  • SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷SecretAgentMan⁰⁰⁷ Lekki, Lagos, Nigeria
    edited July 28 Posts: 2,803
    Mallory wrote: »
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    Ok. But I think Amy Pascal was against that. Or maybe I didn't read it correctly or can't fully remember.

    All the leaks relating to Spectre from the time are on:

    https://bleedingcool.com/movies/when-blofeld-was-a-woman-in-spectre-sony-leaks/

    Makes for a super interesting read.

    Nice. Thanks @Mallory
  • LeonardPineLeonardPine The Bar on the Beach
    Posts: 4,440
    Mallory wrote: »
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    Ok. But I think Amy Pascal was against that. Or maybe I didn't read it correctly or can't fully remember.

    All the leaks relating to Spectre from the time are on:

    https://bleedingcool.com/movies/when-blofeld-was-a-woman-in-spectre-sony-leaks/

    Makes for a super interesting read.

    That was a fascinating read indeed. Thanks @Mallory

    Reading the back and forth it's a surprise they didn't dump the entire thing and start from scratch. What a mess!

    This was an interesting memo from Hannah Mingella:

    "The revelation that Spectre is run by Stockmann – a man still thwarted by the feelings of jealousy he has harbored since he was a young boy desperate for the affection his father showed to Bond – makes Stockmann feel like a petulant kid and somewhat disturbingly links an incredible amount of death and destruction to Bond. Since the idea Bond shared a "father" with Stockmann is introduced so late in the story it doesn't carry the emotional weight desired. By making this a personal attack against Bond it somehow makes the overall threat and ambition of Spectre feel small. Did Stockmann only put all of this in place once Bond became a "00" as a way to taunt him? Was it really all in service of brotherly jealousy?"
  • SeveSeve The island of Lemoy
    Posts: 710
    This was an interesting memo from Hannah Mingella:

    "The revelation that Spectre is run by Stockmann – a man still thwarted by the feelings of jealousy he has harbored since he was a young boy desperate for the affection his father showed to Bond – makes Stockmann feel like a petulant kid and somewhat disturbingly links an incredible amount of death and destruction to Bond. Since the idea Bond shared a "father" with Stockmann is introduced so late in the story it doesn't carry the emotional weight desired. By making this a personal attack against Bond it somehow makes the overall threat and ambition of Spectre feel small. Did Stockmann only put all of this in place once Bond became a "00" as a way to taunt him? Was it really all in service of brotherly jealousy?"

    This is right on the money

    Putting the whole "Austin Powers did it already" aspect to one side for a moment (but only for a moment)

    The actual "Brofeld" idea might have been fine, if only it had been treated as a secondary motivation for the villain. Treating it as Blofeld's primary motivation generates all the issues mentioned above.

    But due to the huge success of CR and SF and the relative failure of QoS, everything always had to be personal for Craig-Bond and over shadow whatever else was going on

    "(Saving) The World Is Not Enough"



  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 18,640
    The problem is it wasn’t really personal for Bond: he never really showed any indication of caring about Oberhauser’s situation.
    More personal to him were following Dench M’s orders and protecting Madeline, and I’d say those bits work much better.
  • SeveSeve The island of Lemoy
    edited 12:48am Posts: 710
    mtm wrote: »
    The problem is it wasn’t really personal for Bond: he never really showed any indication of caring about Oberhauser’s situation.
    More personal to him were following Dench M’s orders and protecting Madeline, and I’d say those bits work much better.

    Or does he just pretend he doesn't care, as a front, to avoid giving Blofeld the gratification he seeks, or perhaps part of a strategy to anoy Blofeld, just as Blofeld is trying to irritate and manipulate Bond with his remarks, just as James Bond has always tried to play it cool during verbal confrontations with Arch villains?

    Blofeld: Why did you come?
    James Bond: I came here to kill you.
    Blofeld: And I thought you came here to die.
    James Bond: Well, it's all a matter of perspective.


  • echoecho 007 in New York
    Posts: 6,882
    Ludovico wrote: »
    Lol. But some of EON's decisions and ideas, though X_X Thank Goodness, Fiennes had to intervene.

    A shame someone didn't also intervene for the 'Brofeld' debacle...

    From what I remember, some did express skepticism, but for whatever reason they decided to go ahead with it.

    Amy Pascal! Which may be why she's right for the new gig.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    edited 7:30am Posts: 18,640
    Seve wrote: »
    mtm wrote: »
    The problem is it wasn’t really personal for Bond: he never really showed any indication of caring about Oberhauser’s situation.
    More personal to him were following Dench M’s orders and protecting Madeline, and I’d say those bits work much better.

    Or does he just pretend he doesn't care, as a front, to avoid giving Blofeld the gratification he seeks, or perhaps part of a strategy to anoy Blofeld, just as Blofeld is trying to irritate and manipulate Bond with his remarks, just as James Bond has always tried to play it cool during verbal confrontations with Arch villains?

    Blofeld: Why did you come?
    James Bond: I came here to kill you.
    Blofeld: And I thought you came here to die.
    James Bond: Well, it's all a matter of perspective.


    Yes I think that’s absolutely their intentions as the earlier script drafts that leaked showed that Bond was pretending not to remember a key moment in Franz’s childhood; but in the finished film I’d say that they missed putting in anything to tell us whether Bond cared or not. We don’t even get any clue about whether he was fond of Hans, let alone his previous feelings about Franz.

    It’s tricky with Bond of course because it is very much in character for him to not let his armour slip, and yet in SF we were very effectively told this was a place of childhood trauma for him which has affected the rest of his life, even without Bond letting his guard down. It’s quite a clever bit of writing.
  • SeveSeve The island of Lemoy
    Posts: 710
    mtm wrote: »

    Yes I think that’s absolutely their intentions as the earlier script drafts that leaked showed that Bond was pretending not to remember a key moment in Franz’s childhood; but in the finished film I’d say that they missed putting in anything to tell us whether Bond cared or not. We don’t even get any clue about whether he was fond of Hans, let alone his previous feelings about Franz.

    It’s tricky with Bond of course because it is very much in character for him to not let his armour slip, and yet in SF we were very effectively told this was a place of childhood trauma for him which has affected the rest of his life, even without Bond letting his guard down. It’s quite a clever bit of writing.

    Good point, the relationship is never developed or explored in any meaningful way, it's merely used as a plot twist for shock value

    Bond could have a conversation scene with someone other than Blofeld, where he reveals his thoughts on the matter, another person from his past perhaps.
Sign In or Register to comment.