Roger Moore's Bond movies; which are your favourites and Why?

124»

Comments

  • edited December 2012 Posts: 13
    Over the last weeks I rewatched the Moore films. The problem I have with his films are that there are fantastic scenes followed by the dumbest scenes (eg. Lotus chase and then a comical shot of Jaws surviving a crash in a house). This is my ranking plus the pros and cons (so far I remeber at the moment):

    1. FYEO
    + chase on foot after Locque and his termination
    + watch with gadget
    + 2CV chase
    + Lotus burglar alarm
    + climbing and the end setting
    + Columbo
    + Melina self confident and not fearful
    + skiing
    + diving

    - Bibi (Thank God Moore resists her offers)
    - the comic end with Thatcher does not really fit the serious tone of the rest of the film

    2. TSWLM
    + watch with gadget
    + Bond in uniform
    + minature boats look more realistic than modern CGI
    + Curd Jürgens as Stromberg
    + the interior of the tanker
    + strong beautiful Bondgirl
    + Lotus racing + diving


    - Jaws, too comical, survives everything
    - hilarious music, when the van in the dessert breaks down

    3. Octopussy
    + car chase in Germany
    + Moore speaks some German
    + PTS
    + Train stunts
    + Plane stunts
    + watch with gadget
    + Louis Jordan, Maud Adams, Kabir Bedi and Steven Berkoff all good

    - Tarzan scene


    4. Moonraker
    + 1h30 classic Bond on earth, great locations
    + 2 boat chases + gadgets (Venice +Brazil)
    + PTS with real stunts
    + outstanding space effects (Many modern CGI effects look worse than the minature effects used here)
    + watch with gadget
    + Michael Lonsdale as Drax

    - Jaws and his silly girlfriend
    - Bond is rescued by US-troops

    6. AVTAK
    + Paris scenes
    + mine set
    + evil girl Mayday

    - silly Hollywood car chase with dumb US-policemen
    - Bondgirl only screams in panic or sighs "James"
    - Moore looks a bit old and fat (often has the hands in the pockets of his jacket to conceal his stomach)
    - PTS music

    5. TMWTGG
    + Scaramanga's Island + interior
    + no big showdown with hundreds of soldiers

    - Bondgirl Goodhead dumb and naive
    - Nicnac
    - silly Kung Fu scenes
    - PTS
    - music ruins the car stunt over the river

    7. LALD
    + watch seen very often and has nice gadgets
    + Kananga's death
    + Boat chase

    - women silly, naive and dumb (especially Rose: how could anyone ever select a person so stupid and easily scared for spy work??? )
    - Bond's clothing
    - Bond dressed up in Harlem
    - voodoo
    - lamest PTS ever, without Bond
    - no real Bond-feeling: too much US cars and settings, Bond uses a big revolver, smokes several cigars


    I noticed that Moore only has a company car in two films, in the others he just steels a vehicle (bus, boat, AMC car , (Moonraker), Alfa, Mercedes, firetruck ...)
  • 4EverBonded4EverBonded the Ballrooms of Mars
    edited December 2012 Posts: 12,459
    My very fav Moore film: The Spy Who Loved Me (FYEO is a close 2nd)
    I fell in love with Roger in this one (and that is my main reason for loving it so) ... and that first spark still hasn't died for me.
    I liked the story very much, Bach was fine, locations great, everything was well paced and just plain interesting, exciting, and fun. I can watch it again and again and again.
  • Nice, another TSWLM fan.


    I don't mind FYEO but I think it's a bit overrated. I think lots of people put it as Moore's best film just because it's more serious than Moore's other films. I think Moore is good and Glen is my favourite Bond director but it gave Blofeld a terrible death, the villian was fairly forgettable and some of the action wasn't great imo.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,698
    but it gave Blofeld a terrible death
    The more I think about it, the more I kinda like his being poor & vengeful, putting together that crap attempt to kill Bond, and getting dumped in a smokestack for his trouble...
    :))
  • LordBrettSinclairLordBrettSinclair Greensleeves
    Posts: 167
    I tried to rank the movies and I did.
    Here all 7 Moore movies in my ranking.

    1 FYEO
    2 TSWLM
    3 OP
    7 LALD
    10 MR
    12 TMWTGG
    13 AVTAK

    I love Roger Moore, clearly my favorite Bond.

    Love all 7 almost equally. Only AVTAK is most clear for being last, but just because I feel, finally and sadly, Moore got too old for the role.

    No other Bond actor has such a variety of great Bond movies, not even Connery.

    LALD = voodoo, tarot theme, slight suspense/horror movie quality
    TMWTGG = exotic, strange, most iconic villain, black humor
    TSWLM = redefined Bond, Moore find the definite way to play Bond, pyramids, underwater Lotus, so many memorable images
    MR = even at jumping on Star Wars train, succeeds being original with Bond in space, Rio is another classic location and setting for Bond including the mountain cable car sequence. Bringing Jaws back makes MR feel like sort of sequel to TSWLM. Humor is priceless!
    FYEO = at right time back to basics. Moore never better in the role than here. Classic Bond feel with beautiful mediterranean setting. Bond on skis, Bond under water, Bond on mountain, Bond in car, Bond in air. Has it all plus Carole Bouquet perfect perfect Bond girl.
    OP = fantastic fantasy adventure feel, best villain Kamal Khan, Octopussy classic Bond woman with power, best cold war story since 60s. Cast is great!
    AVTAK = Eiffel Tower, iconic. Grace Jones unique Bond girl and work well with Walken who is most crazy Bond villain. Golden Gate bridge, again iconic to this day, just the picture of it with Bond standing on it is pop culture.

    In all of this, there is the great various music of the one-off composers and John Barry. What a brilliant mix.
    The stunt work in the Moore era never was equalled overall, even if Dalton and Brosnan had some great stunt work as well.

    Connery made Bond 60s era phenomenon. But Bond would have died if Connery had stayed on.

    Moore redefined Bond and added greatly, that way future is still save for Bond.

    I can watch the 7 movies at any time. Never boring, always fun and humor stays. I can always laugh even if heard jokes for 100 times. Roger Moore so naturally performs, like be himself which feels great and brings good vibe on screen. Never feel tries to "act". Only one other Bond actor accomplished this too, Connery.

    Roger Moore in commander's uniform is unrivaled. Just looks so great!

    FYEO will always be my favorite, probably because of Locque, Columbo, Melina, Kriegler and even Bibi. What a cast of completely different characters thrown together in one movie and it works so perfectly.
    Also Melina is one strong, determined, woman, the moment we realize she has taken revenge with her cross bow is always giving me chills. The moment we see the hate in her eyes early in the movie with camera zooming in on her face. It simply does not get better than that. That's emotion!

    TSWLM probably is the most classic and loved of Moore's, it also was clearly his most successful in terms of ticket sales who went up back to heights of Connery 60s era.
    Together with OP, TSWLM are my No 2 really, hard to decide which I like more.
    Both so different but wonderful settings. The contrast of cold Berlin/train/circus/Russia setting to warm exotic setting of Kamal Khan's world is great and makes OP special, has even a adventure feel to it at times.

    LALD and TMWTGG would be my No 3. I give LALD slightly better notes because of most unique setting of suspense voodoo, tarot world with unique Bond girl, clairvoyant tarot reader. The carribean island contrasting New York, then my favorite Felix Leiter. Filet O Soul is a great set, the turning table and the hidden office behind makes for some of my favorite scenes in the movie.
    The stunt work is astonishing in LALD, just look at the crocodile stunt, the boat chase the car stunts etc.
    The soundtrack is my favorite!
    But then TMWTGG has so much to love too. A lovely, sexy, innocent and somewhat dumb Bond girl who does more harm than help but how charming she is! And if you watch closely Bond gives her quite a hard time, so we should be a bit more tolerant towards her.
    Scaramanga is THE Bond villain. Lee makes it his role and for me best villain overall. The fun house one of most original sets of all Bond movies. I love it to bits. And there is so much more to love and look forward to whenever I watch it.
    J.W. Pepper, every single word is priceless and the actor absolutely owns the screen. So happy they brought him back in TMWTGG.

    AVTAK
    Roger Moore's last and maybe one too many Bond movies understandably gets a lot of criticism.
    But once you get past Mr Moore's age you can discover a throughout funny movie with lots of great action.
    The Golden Gate Bridge sequence, the Eiffel Tower sequence, the Town Hall sequence, the Mine sequence. All very different and all work well. MayDay and Zorin make a great couple. If anything then maybe Tanya Roberts can go on nerves at times but I find the home cooking scene with the Quiche sweet and it plays wonderfully with Roger's age.
    The saucy bit with the Russian spy Pola is quite funny including the ending in General Gogol's car.

    As said, I have trouble choosing a ranking with those movies. I can but it is all awfully close together.

    The more time passes, the more I enjoy Moore's movies. I tried the same with Dalton which is roughly in the same time but it's just not the same for me. What came after Dalton never really captured me, with exception of Goldeneye and now Spectre.

    For me Tandem Connery/Moore with Lazenby sandwiched in between makes the Bond franchise. Bond still is good overall and nice to see gets new generations of fans still but for me it will always come back to the first 3 decades.
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    LALD. Because he played Bond and not Moore.
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    Based on the ranking I finished a couple of months ago...

    TSWLM (4)
    FYEO (6)
    OP (10)
    LALD (11)
    TMWTGG (14)
    MR (16)
    AVTAK (19)

    The first two will (probably) never change, but the others move around a bit from year to year.
  • NSGWNSGW London
    edited January 2017 Posts: 299
    I'm similar to Birdleson in how my top two lie, TMWTGG I just find to be so fun and re watchable, plus Christopher Lee is one of my favourite villains. I can't say I don't enjoy any Moore adventure there's just too much too make you smile.

    TSWLM
    LALD
    TMWTGG
    FYEO
    MR
    OP
    AVTAK
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    edited January 2017 Posts: 6,825
    I think Rog was actually at his best in his first two outings.
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    Agreed.
  • bondjamesbondjames You were expecting someone else?
    edited January 2017 Posts: 23,883
    TSWLM - clear winner for me. A near perfect larger than life Bond film and the last time all those big elements came together so seamlessly. I can't believe it's 40 years old! Sir Roger Moore is just so smooth in this one. It has always been and always be a top 10 film of all time for me, even though I rank it a little lower in comparison to some other Bond films on a critical scale here. Just love it!

    OP - for Moore's effortlessly cool performance despite his obviously advancing years, and for the sheer entertainment value of the film. It's probably the most fast paced of Sir Rog's outings, and such a blast from start to finish, with one of the most charismatic villain rosters in all of Bondom.

    LALD - such a unique entry. Moore is super cool and so Bondian in his debut. Again, I love a charismatic villain roster, and it doesn't get much better than in this film. The George Martin score is the icing on the cake.

    TMWTGG - sentimentally, this is one of my favourites. It was one of the earliest Bond films I watched with my parents on ITV, and it made an indelible impression. So quirky and stylish at the same time. I honestly think some of Moore's best scenes are in this film (Lazar, dinner with Scaramanga, dinner with Goodnight, Andrea interrogation, fight at Saida's, etc. etc.).

    FYEO - critically this is one of his best, but subjectively I'm not too keen on it. A bit dull, but on the flip side I love Bouquet as the original revenge girl Melina Havelock (not bettered imho - if eyes could pierce, with a steely outer demeanour masking volative inner emotions which are almost frightening to contemplate). The ski sequence is the best since OHMSS (and better in some instances) and the cinematography is outstanding. Beautiful film to watch on blu ray.

    MR - again, this is a sentimental favourite of mine. Sir Rog on fire (his most coolly assured performance, even if he is having too much fun in places), Drax is outstanding and memorable, Goodhead proves her worth, & the film has magnificent cinematography, location work and scale.

    AVTAK - I realize some like this film, but I can't stand it. Sir Rog should have gone out on an all time high with the previous effort. Disappointing all round and down there with TWINE, DAD & SP as one of the misfires in the franchise's history.
  • LordBrettSinclairLordBrettSinclair Greensleeves
    edited January 2017 Posts: 167
    .
  • 1) TSWLM. A classic. GF and YOLT may have invented the big, cinematic Bond formula but I think this one perfected it. One of those films where everything just comes together perfectly.

    2) OP. A close second. Orlov is awful, the PTS feels tacked on and the jungle chase is crap. But apart from that there's very little I don't enjoy in this one. Moore on top form. Barry too. Memorable characters and set pieces and the best plot of all the Moore films with a brilliantly tense finale.

    3) LALD. Great villains, great score, Moore nails it, an amazing stunt, a cool supernatural theme, etc. I can't imagine what a breath of fresh air this must have felt when it came out. Make Solitaire black, cut the airport chase (have Solitaire be recaptured before they escape San Monique) and the boat chase and Pepper entirely and give it a whole new finale (so fresh and interesting then suddenly we're just in Bond by the numbers territory, complete with a shark pit) and this one would be a classic imo. As it stands it's really enjoyable but falls apart towards the end and there are some racist/imperialist overtones that rub me the wrong way.

    4) AVTAK. Moore is too old. Stacey is crap. The action isn't very good (this can basically be put down to Moore's age) apart from the finale and the Eiffel Tower base jump. The plot is basically Goldfinger. But Zorin is brilliant, and the score is one of Barry's best.

    5) FYEO. Not a fan at all if I'm honest. Tonally it's a complete mess, tries to be all gritty and dark but still has the usual Moore camp so it just comes across as jarring. Brings Bond back down to earth but ends up being so bland and forgettable in the proccess. Probably the worst PTS of the series. Forgettable villain, forgettable plot, etc. Score is awful too. Probably the most forgettable film of the series for me.

    6) TMWTGG. I was tempted to put this above FYEO because of Scaramanga but in a way that makes it worse. This film has so much potential and totally squanders it. This is also the only film where I'm not a fan of Moore in the role (after a brilliant debut he's reduced to a subpar Connery impression).

    7) MR. Bond in space could be many things but you wouldn't think boring would be one of them (to be fair the space scenes are one of the few enjoyable bits thanks to Barry and the brilliant special effects). Even if you take out the cringey comedic bits it'd be a dull bloated followup to TSWLM. Bond by the numbers is fine as long as there's an energy to it, as long as it feels fresh, it's done well and has some interesting ideas (TSWLM, GE, SP). MR is the opposite. A boring box ticking mess that's only remembered for the space stuff and the crap bits before we get there. A handful of good scenes can't save it from being Moore's worst imo (although to be fair I wouldn't say TMWTGG is any better, they can be joint last).
Sign In or Register to comment.