MI6: Best Bond Film Results

135

Comments

  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    Posts: 4,012
    OK...having had my long-winded say on why I do not like OHMSS and seeing how highly it is thought of by many of the posters here, I would like to know what you all find so appealing about the movie. Why do you rate it so highly amongst the others in the series?

    OHMSS is a great film, with a wonderful story based on a great book, with an excellent Bond-girl, breathtaking locations, great stunt work, absolutely top soundtrack, it has drama and action in right amounts, the list could go on and on. Of course it has many flaws and the biggest of them all was the main actor, sadly. But still it is one of the best Bond films in my opinion (and I'm obviously not alone) and I'm happy it got a good place in this pole.
  • WillardWhyteWillardWhyte Midnight Society #ProjectMoon
    Posts: 784
    cant really argue with that list..my favorite two films are reversed but thats alright (FRWL and CR)
  • Posts: 5,745
    Please don't generalize here. I could probably outmatch you on film trivia from the 40s and 50s. Just because someone is young doesn't mean they don't know a classic film.

    But you'd agree that most people your age couldn't match your knowledge of classic films. That's his point. It's statistically true that people are more likely to embrace films of their generation than those of previous generations. Not generalization.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/movies/news/a410222/casino-royale-voted-best-james-bond-movie-by-digital-spy-users.html

    Digital Spy's list...

    1. Casino Royale - 21.2%
    2. GoldenEye - 13.7%
    3. Goldfinger - 9.8%
    4. Live and Let Die - 6.1%
    5. The Spy Who Loved Me - 5.8%
    6. On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 5.8%
    7. From Russia with Love - 5.0%
    8. Licence to Kill - 3.6%
    9. The Living Daylights - 3.3%
    10. You Only Live Twice - 3.2%
    11. A View to a Kill - 2.9%
    12. Tomorrow Never Dies - 2.6%
    13. The World Is Not Enough - 2.4%
    14. Die Another Day - 2.2%
    15. The Man with the Golden Gun - 1.9%
    16. Moonraker - 1.9%
    17. For Your Eyes Only - 1.7%
    18. Octopussy - 1.5%
    19. Quantum of Solace - 1.5%
    20. Dr No - 1.4%
    21. Diamonds are Forever - 1.3%
    22. Thunderball - 1.3%
  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    Posts: 4,012
    RC7 wrote:
    http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/movies/news/a410222/casino-royale-voted-best-james-bond-movie-by-digital-spy-users.html

    Digital Spy's list...

    1. Casino Royale - 21.2%
    2. GoldenEye - 13.7%
    3. Goldfinger - 9.8%
    4. Live and Let Die - 6.1%
    5. The Spy Who Loved Me - 5.8%
    6. On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 5.8%
    7. From Russia with Love - 5.0%
    8. Licence to Kill - 3.6%
    9. The Living Daylights - 3.3%
    10. You Only Live Twice - 3.2%
    11. A View to a Kill - 2.9%
    12. Tomorrow Never Dies - 2.6%
    13. The World Is Not Enough - 2.4%
    14. Die Another Day - 2.2%
    15. The Man with the Golden Gun - 1.9%
    16. Moonraker - 1.9%
    17. For Your Eyes Only - 1.7%
    18. Octopussy - 1.5%
    19. Quantum of Solace - 1.5%
    20. Dr No - 1.4%
    21. Diamonds are Forever - 1.3%
    22. Thunderball - 1.3%

    This one is odd for me, FRWL in 7th place? Should never be out of the top 3 in my opinion. the last 5-6 would also be misplaced if I made the list (DAD, MR and AVTAK in around the middle makes me cringe). The mi6 results seem to be much more equilibrated in my opinion.
  • Creasy47Creasy47 In Cuba with Natalya.Moderator
    Posts: 40,172
    I agree: the more people dive into something, the most recent the film that they relate with, which seems to be a typical point for how people get into the world of Bond. Brosnan and GE? My favorite Bond and film, respectively, because that's what introduced me to the world of James Bond.

    But, just like @0BradyM0Bondfanatic7, I'm not like the other "young" 21-year-olds such as myself. I am in love with the older Bond films - they're some of my favorites, and I would say a majority of them are on my Top 10 - and older films in general. Don't generalize a group of people when you don't know all of them.
  • I prefer digital spies list because LTK was higher :)
    OK...having had my long-winded say on why I do not like OHMSS and seeing how highly it is thought of by many of the posters here, I would like to know what you all find so appealing about the movie. Why do you rate it so highly amongst the others in the series?

    OHMSS isn't my favourite but it has always been in my top 10. I think it has great music, I think Lazenby did really well (especially when you think about how he'd never acted before), the sets are great, the music is great, the action is great and the ending is one of the best in the whole series.

    There's one problem I have with OHMSS: The angels of death story is just stupid. I mean, brainwashing? It's just too sci fi, like MR or DAD's plot.
  • I'm okay with how the poll turned out. I'm really glad OHMSS got in the top five! My top ten would have been like so:

    1. FRWL
    2. CR
    3. TLD
    4. OHMSS
    5. GF
    6. YOLT
    7. LALD
    8. QOS
    9. LTK
    10. TSWLM
  • 0BradyM0Bondfanatic70BradyM0Bondfanatic7 Quantum Floral Arrangements: "We Have Petals Everywhere"
    Posts: 28,694
    I'm okay with how the poll turned out. I'm really glad OHMSS got in the top five! My top ten would have been like so:

    1. FRWL
    2. CR
    3. TLD
    4. OHMSS
    5. GF
    6. YOLT
    7. LALD
    8. QOS
    9. LTK
    10. TSWLM
    QoS in the top ten! Nice pick, mate!
    =D>
  • Lancaster007Lancaster007 Shrublands Health Clinic, England
    Posts: 1,874
    There's one problem I have with OHMSS: The angels of death story is just stupid. I mean, brainwashing? It's just too sci fi, like MR or DAD's plot.


    How is brainwashing Sci-Fi? A technique that's been used for hundreds if not thousands of years is stupid and sci-fi! Actually very plausible.
  • doubleonothingdoubleonothing Los Angeles Moderator
    Posts: 864
    I think this list just shows there is a strong diversity amongst Bond fans as to what they like the most.
    We're actually really lucky to have so many films with such a different and varied tone and style between them, all featuring our favourite hero.
    It wouldn't be my ranking, but it's not far off.
  • There's one problem I have with OHMSS: The angels of death story is just stupid. I mean, brainwashing? It's just too sci fi, like MR or DAD's plot.


    How is brainwashing Sci-Fi? A technique that's been used for hundreds if not thousands of years is stupid and sci-fi! Actually very plausible.

    I've never heard any stories about it actually happening. Maybe not sci fi, but unrealistic.
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    There's one problem I have with OHMSS: The angels of death story is just stupid. I mean, brainwashing? It's just too sci fi, like MR or DAD's plot.


    How is brainwashing Sci-Fi? A technique that's been used for hundreds if not thousands of years is stupid and sci-fi! Actually very plausible.

    I've never heard any stories about it actually happening. Maybe not sci fi, but unrealistic.

    Ever heard of religion?

    Do you think these Islamic fundamentalists are born wanting to blow themselves up?
  • But most of them have probably had it drilled into them from the day they were born.

    With the Angels of Death, they just had Blofeld talk to them when they were sleeping and suddenly they were lethal weapons.
  • edited October 2012 Posts: 3,494
    There's one problem I have with OHMSS: The angels of death story is just stupid. I mean, brainwashing? It's just too sci fi, like MR or DAD's plot.

    How is brainwashing Sci-Fi? A technique that's been used for hundreds if not thousands of years is stupid and sci-fi! Actually very plausible.

    I thoroughly agree with you. This is what cults do, maybe not as dramatically but this is Hollywood after all. The AOD's would probably never willingly do Blofeld's bidding. I see no comparison to MR where these so-called "perfect specimens" (a running joke like most of the film) wanted to be a part of Drax's plot. DAD was merely building and reinforcing a new persona, again they wanted to do that.
  • Overall I'm happy with the list. Just shows the vast majority mainly share my taste. Most at or near the top are amongst my favs and most at or near the bottom are correct also. I wouldn't have MR rock bottom, that needs elevating a few places.
  • Posts: 1,497
    I'd say this list sums up the zeitgeist of opinion pretty well. CR got the one spot because it is a most recent favorite. I think GE also is favored because of the current generation and it's association with both the video game and the Bond rebirth of '95.

    Hypothetically speaking, if not another single Bond film was ever made again, and this list was re-polled in 50 years time, I doubt CR or GE would rank so highly. I'm not slighting those films, I just think those films are more 'current' and were generally well received, so they are still 'hot' in people's minds.

    OHMSS probably wouldn't have polled well in say the 70's or 80's, but that film has earned a respect over time for being a very solid film, even if it wasn't popular at the time.
  • edited October 2012 Posts: 4,762
    OK...having had my long-winded say on why I do not like OHMSS and seeing how highly it is thought of by many of the posters here, I would like to know what you all find so appealing about the movie. Why do you rate it so highly amongst the others in the series?

    Thank you sir, thank you very much! I too do not highly enjoy On Her Majesty's Secret Service! Welcome to the "OHMSS Dislike Club"! Glad to have another member to our exclusive party! (there aren't many of us, sadly)
  • Posts: 4,622
    JamesPage wrote:
    Just how are these results calculated exactly?

    Give the article a re-read, and let us know if you have any questions. There aren't too many words.
    Just because your personal opinions do not match the average of 15,000+ other fans does not mean the process is flawed.
    I'm not quite sure how the results are tabulated. I get that CR scores first because it was included on 75% of top-5 lists and that MR and AVTAK appeared on the least number of top -5 lists, but how was the data from the lists of the 5 least-liked films incorported into the survey?
    The fact that that CR appears on so many top-5 lists I think indicates its broad general appeal among cross-generations of Bond fans,even if it might not top a list of the most #1 votes, although it might. I'm not sure which film would top that list.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    00Beast wrote:
    Welcome to the "OHMSS Dislike Club"! Glad to have another member to our exclusive party! (there aren't many of us, sadly)

    The reason for that is because it's an awesome film.
  • Posts: 4,762
    RC7 wrote:
    00Beast wrote:
    Welcome to the "OHMSS Dislike Club"! Glad to have another member to our exclusive party! (there aren't many of us, sadly)

    The reason for that is because it's an awesome film.

    Or because people just go with the flow of popular opinion around here when it comes to OHMSS.
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    JamesPage wrote:
    Just how are these results calculated exactly?

    Give the article a re-read, and let us know if you have any questions. There aren't too many words.
    Just because your personal opinions do not match the average of 15,000+ other fans does not mean the process is flawed.

    Sorry but all I would like clarified is does appearing in someone's top 5 carry equal weight for each film or do positions 1-5 within that top 5 count for different points depending on the ranking? This is not made clear in the article - however few words it has for my tiny brain to process.

    I guess of the 15k who voted only a tiny percentage post on these forums because although I think most of us respect GF for what it did for the series I don't see a great deal of love for it on here and find it's position at number 2 rather surprising.
  • edited October 2012 Posts: 3,494
    00Beast wrote:
    RC7 wrote:
    00Beast wrote:
    Welcome to the "OHMSS Dislike Club"! Glad to have another member to our exclusive party! (there aren't many of us, sadly)

    The reason for that is because it's an awesome film.

    Or because people just go with the flow of popular opinion around here when it comes to OHMSS.

    Not true for OHMSS as far as I am concerned. I don't follow the pack anymore than anyone else. Many of your peers see the value in this film. Although I fail to see why people are fans of Lazenby, otherwise the rest of the cast and their performances are as great as a movie gets, breathtaking cinematography, a killer soundtrack, and a story that has a major influence on the Bond character portrayed mostly the way Fleming himself wrote about and would have approved of. The problem is with those who prefer tons of flying bullets over a touching, meaningful, and personal story. The Bond classics mix action to augment the story, which is why you don't get it. But I know you are young and I have hope that someday the light bulb will come on for you between this and GF :)


  • Posts: 144
    Can we all at least agree that anyone who doesn't have FRWL in their top 5 is a horrible Nazi loving donkey raping scumbag???
  • edited October 2012 Posts: 3,494
    OddJaws wrote:
    Can we all at least agree that anyone who doesn't have FRWL in their top 5 is a horrible Nazi loving donkey raping scumbag???

    Absofreakinglutely. And without vaseline to boot :D
  • Well my #1 pick won. Also that's a good top 5. Personally I wouldn't have included GE but I can understand its popularity.
  • Posts: 144
    OddJaws wrote:
    Can we all at least agree that anyone who doesn't have FRWL in their top 5 is a horrible Nazi loving donkey raping scumbag???

    Absofreakinglutely. And without vaseline to boot :D
    My man right here..

  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    OddJaws wrote:
    OddJaws wrote:
    Can we all at least agree that anyone who doesn't have FRWL in their top 5 is a horrible Nazi loving donkey raping scumbag???

    Absofreakinglutely. And without vaseline to boot :D
    My man right here..

    Seems a bit harsh on the poor donkey chaps!
  • MI6MI6 Administrator
    Posts: 677
    The official Facebook 007 fan page polled its followers and came up with these results
  • Posts: 51
    Casino Royale?! I'll never understand the obsession with that film. Objectively it was a very good film, but it also butchered the Bond formula/template.

    #2-9 should have been #1-8 more or less in the same order with (CR can be thrown is as #4). Also, Moonraker wasn't as bad as A View to a Kill. Even with the campiness, it was an entertaining film, while A View to a Kill was almost painful to watch (Walken saved the film).
Sign In or Register to comment.