The great Bond directors elimination game

1468910

Comments

  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 55
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 13
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 15
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 32
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27 (-2)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51 (+1)

    07. Sam Mendes SF - 13

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 3,336
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 55
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 11 -2
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 15
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 32
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52 (+1)
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 13

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • AntiLocqueBrakesAntiLocqueBrakes The edge
    Posts: 538
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56 (+1)
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 11
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 15
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 30 (-2)
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 13

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56 (+1)
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 9 (-2)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 15
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 30
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 14 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD[/quote]

  • Posts: 1,066
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10 (+1)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 14 (-1)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 30
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26 (-1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 14

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 486
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 14
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 30
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27 (+1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 50 (-2)

    07. Sam Mendes SF - 14

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • BondJasonBond006BondJasonBond006 on fb and ajb
    Posts: 9,020
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 14
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 30
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28 (+1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 50
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 12 (-2)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 16
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 14
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28 (-2)
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 50
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 13 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • MooseWithFleasMooseWithFleas Philadelphia
    Posts: 3,333
    Monday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 15 +1
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 50
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11 (-2)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 12,243
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 10
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 13 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51 (+1)
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • MansfieldMansfield Where the hell have you been?
    Posts: 1,263
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 8 (-2)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 13
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 12 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7 (-2)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 13
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29 (+1)
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 7,500
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 11 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 9 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 28
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 12 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • DrShatterhandDrShatterhand Garden of Death, near Belfast
    Posts: 805
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 10 (+1)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26 (-2)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 51
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 12

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD

  • Posts: 3,336
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 10
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52 +1
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10 -2

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 6 (-1)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 9 (-1)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 29
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD[/quote]

  • edited October 2015 Posts: 1,631
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 6
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 9
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28 (-1)
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27 (+1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10 (-1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 1,066
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7 (+1)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 7 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 27
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 52
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 7
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 7
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 25 (-2)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53 (+1)

    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Aziz_FekkeshAziz_Fekkesh Royale-les-Eaux
    edited October 2015 Posts: 403
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 56
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5 (-2)
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 7
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 28
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 25
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • AntiLocqueBrakesAntiLocqueBrakes The edge
    Posts: 538
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 57 (+1)
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 7
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26 (-2)
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 25
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • M_BaljeM_Balje Amsterdam, Netherlands
    edited October 2015 Posts: 4,416
    Tuesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 57 (+1)
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 7
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26 (+1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 9 (- 2)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • 01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 58 +1
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 5 -2
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 9

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • MansfieldMansfield Where the hell have you been?
    Posts: 1,263
    Wednesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 58
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 3 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 10 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • MansfieldMansfield Where the hell have you been?
    Posts: 1,263
    Inconceivable is a little bit harsh. Quantity is only a marginal factor in this in my mind anyway, but maybe that's just a way for me to express my slight bias. Mendes captured a lot of magic in a film that admittedly has flaws. It's difficult for me to gauge the quality of Hamilton and Gilbert with both very good and very poor efforts. It's hard to imagine someone of Mendes' esteem directing a DAF, TMWTGG, or MR.
  • Posts: 12,243
    Mansfield wrote: »
    Inconceivable is a little bit harsh. Quantity is only a marginal factor in this in my mind anyway, but maybe that's just a way for me to express my slight bias. Mendes captured a lot of magic in a film that admittedly has flaws. It's difficult for me to gauge the quality of Hamilton and Gilbert with both very good and very poor efforts. It's hard to imagine someone of Mendes' esteem directing a DAF, TMWTGG, or MR.

    Agreed. While I really like films such as GF, LALD, and TSWLM, DAF and MR are two of the series' biggest duds for me. SF is also one of my personal favorites, so there you go.
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Wednesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 58
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 5
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 1 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 26
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 53
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 11 (+1)

    Eliminated:
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 12,243
    Wednesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 58
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 6
    03. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR - 0 (-1) ELIMINATED
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 25 (-1)
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 54 (+1)
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 9

    Eliminated:
    07. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
  • Posts: 7,500
    Wednesday

    01. Terence Young - DN / FRWL / TB - 59 (+1)
    02. Guy Hamilton - GF / DAF / LALD / TMWTGG - 4 (-2)
    04. Peter Hunt - OHMSS - 26
    05. John Glen - FYEO / OP / AVTAK / TLD / LTK - 25
    06. Martin Campbell - GE / CR - 54
    07. Sam Mendes SF - 9

    Eliminated:
    07. Lewis Gilbert - YOLT / TSWLM / MR
    08. Marc Forster - QOS
    09. Roger Spottiswoode - TND
    10. Michael Apted - TWINE
    11. Lee Tamahori - DAD
Sign In or Register to comment.