It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
I like this one - every time I watch it I like it more and more. I think the Bond/Bourne comparisons aren't completely accurate. A lot of the action is framed and shot beautifully in QOS.
Love the fight with Slate - there's a real grittyness to the entire fight and shows how Bond is different than Bourne with Bond taking the time to clean himself up.
Craig is on fire. The scene aboard the plane is one of the best scenes from Craig's era and David Arnold nails it. I wish a couple of piano notes from her theme would've also been inserted into SP when Bond picks up Vesper's interrogation tape in La'Americana.
The biggest problem with QOS is that it follows Casino Royale. Any film would've had a hard time following up to it. In fact, I would say that an issue is that in a series of 24 films, I just can't rank it higher as much as I enjoy it.
01. From Russia With Love
02. Casino Royale '06
03. Dr. No
04. GoldenEye
05. Octopussy
06. The Spy Who Loved Me
07. Quantum Of Solace
08. You Only Live Twice
09. SPECTRE
10. The World Is Not Enough
11. A View To A Kill
12. Moonraker
13. Never Say Never Again
http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/1117/quantum-of-solace-appreciation-thread-we-found-a-better-place-to-meet#latest
I used to have this one in my bottom three. Over time, I have come to appreciate Lee's performance as Scaramanga. There are some decent scenes, but like Moonraker and A View To A Kill, scenes that should be memorable for punctuated with poor attempts at humor. The slide whistle completely destroys a great stunt. JW Pepper has no reason being in the movie. The duel on Scaramanga's island is reason enough for me to rank it where I do.
Also, I don't really care for Roger Moore's performance in this one. I don't buy him slapping around Maud Adams, it comes off as mean spirited, especially since she's written as a troubled soul looking for help.
01. From Russia With Love
02. Casino Royale '06
03. Dr. No
04. GoldenEye
05. Octopussy
06. The Spy Who Loved Me
07. Quantum Of Solace
08. You Only Live Twice
09. SPECTRE
10. The World Is Not Enough
11. The Man With The Golden Gun
12. A View To A Kill
13. Moonraker
14. Never Say Never Again
"Who knows? Maybe he will even use one of those little golden bullets on you. That would be very unfortunate...because they're very expensive." Moore's deadpan delivery on that line however makes me laugh every time.
I've actually never made that connection until now. Spot on.
This one is interesting to watch today. If you've been sitting under a rock this past year, I would say the idea of a corrupt media giant creating headlines for ratings isn't so much a stretch anymore.
Tomorrow Never Dies starts off great: some decent action, the sinking of the Devonshire, Bond getting called into action as the entire situation inches closer and closer to another world war. I love the scene where Bond is standing in the terminal looking at the Tomorrow headlines about the rising tensions and the accompanied music. I've long thought this was Arnold's weakest score but it still tops anything Newman put out - if this had been Newman, the only time the Bond theme would've showed up was Bond driving the DB5 to headquarters.
The scenes inside the printing factory are great. It's a shame that the majority of the rest of the action in the film are so generic.
Never been a fan of the motorcycle chase. Either the way it's shot or edited fails to impress me and the score doesn't generate any tension or memorable moments. The final battle aboard the stealth ship is devoid of any suspense.
Carver has one of the more unfortunate deaths...delicious.
Generic. That's the best way to describe this one. I can't think of one category where I say this one is close to being the best.
1. From Russia With Love
2. Casino Royale '06
3. Dr. No
4. GoldenEye
5. Octopussy
6. The Spy Who Loved Me
7. Quantum Of Solace
8. You Only Live Twice
9. SPECTRE
10. The World Is Not Enough
11. The Man With The Golden Gun
12. A View To A Kill
13. Moonraker
14. Tomorrow Never Dies
15. Never Say Never Again
I used to like this but now it's kind of lame. The scenes with Rosie Carver now really grate and add nothing to the film. Just like the chase around the airport could have been cut out.
The speedboat chase is still enjoyable and the climax with Baron Samedi and the Shark tank is spooky and atmospheric.
The fight on the train is also pretty good.
But overall I think this could be the weakest Moore effort.
Indeed a mixed bag. Great score, Great Bond, very stylish, unique and memorable, great set of villains, great Bond girl but many lame stuff, and a very unsatisfying death of the main villain, Rosie Carver is bad and the ending anticlmactic. The PTS is not a very good opening, they should have focused on one scene. The action is also not that great, except for the boat chase, even though it lacks any score and is a bit too long.
However, the film is sprinkled with some great lines.
Indeed the score is excellent. So is the theme song.
I find Moore all to flippant and lightweight in the film. He is much better in TMWTGG.
Me too. My dad took me to see it when I was six. Scared the crap out of me! All that voodoo!
I feel the whole movie lacks a punch. Once Bond gets to Hamburg, I think any suspense the film has evaporates. Everything is just so by the numbers.
Another thing I've noticed recently that helps detach me from any excitement during the action scenes is the heightened, cheesy sound effects when someone lands a punch. So cartoonish.
Well said.
I have rewatched 11 films of the series now. My conclusions so far:
- Dr. No: 8/10
- Goldfinger: 8/10
- You Only Live Twice: 6/10
- On Her Majesty's Secret Service: 10/10
- Live and Let Die: 9/10
- The Spy Who Loved Me: 7/10
- Moonraker: 6/10
- Never Say Never Again: 6/10
- Licence to Kill: 10/10
- GoldenEye: 9/10
- Tomorrow Never Dies: 6/10
Next up: Diamonds Are Forever.
Another stellar John Barry score. Also, DAF is probably my favourite Shirley Bassey Bond song. Ken Adam bringing some great set design to the show as usual, especially the Whyte penthouse is amazing. Excellent title sequence by Binder, with cats and diamonds all over the place. DAF is Connery's best gunbarrel too.
I like the 1970's atmosphere, both in Amsterdam and Las Vegas. The car chase and the elevator fight are great stunts and I've always liked the PTS as well. The oil rig finale isn't great however, I'm glad the film has one decent action scene after that one.
Jill St. John isn't my favourite Bond girl, but she's all right. Lana Wood not so much but her screentime is limited. Norman Burton is a bit dull as Felix, even though he does get something more to do than most colleagues in the role.
Always liked Charles Gray hamming it up as Blofeld. Same goes for Wint & Kidd. I like the dialogue in this film and I realized that I miss modern Bond knowing his wines. That look Connery gives when he says: "Mouton Rothschild IS a claret." Priceless.
8/10
Good, it is top 5 for me.
One of the most positive experiences I've had with this film. Dalton is a complete badass.