Battle of 4 Bond films: 'FRWL' vs. 'OHMSS' vs. 'CR' vs 'SF'

Gustav_Graves

You can only pick one of these four! Which if these four is your ultimate favourite. You need to pick one! No arguments ;-).

Samuel001

Repost this idea here. It may be just what is needed to revive this thread:

http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/2274/bond-movie-a-vs.-bond-movie-b-dr.-no-vs.-skyfall

Gustav_Graves

Sorry, that's not what I meant. I carefully choose these four Bond films. I want forummmbers to mention just one film without (too much) arguments. Then I count the results and add them up.

Why these four films? I consider them the most Fleming-esque, most intelligent espionage thrillers. So mine would be:....

Gustav_Graves

'Skyfall' !

Samuel001

I understand, but you know what some people are like. Before you know it, threads will be everywhere comparing four random films.

From Russia With Love would be my choice.

Gustav_Graves

I'll mod it a bit ;-). No worries. My goal is to find out which of these four is the most popular.

Standings 22.06.2013:
--> 1 vote: 'FRWL'
--> 0 vote: 'OHMSS'
--> 0 vote: 'CR'
--> 1 vote: 'SF'

dalton

From Russia With Love would definitely be my choice out of the four.

chrisisall

Count me in for CR!

Soundofthesinners

From Russia with Love. Very close all around, though.

4EverBonded

Skyfall

Germanlady

CR and SF equally.

002

This is Not News


and obviously the one missing is Goldeneye to make this whole thread....

CraigMooreOHMSS

002 wrote:

This is Not News


and obviously the one missing is Goldeneye to make this whole thread....

Agreed. That said, my vote goes to FRWL.

DarthDimi

Not news and we have agreed in the past not to keep these 'versus' threads alive. Unfortunately they can spawn, within a week, a gazillion threads comparing two or three or more Bond films. We could end up with literally hundreds of those - and we once came very close to that - making things a bit chaotic around here. What's even more, most of these threads ended up with one page of posts at best and then withered. Lastly, as @Samuel001 pointed out, it usually does end up in people just randomly discussing these films. The 'Movie A vs Movie B' thread was created to collect all possible combinations and permutations under one single roof.

Some examples of past attempts:
http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/121/frwl-vs-ohmss-/p1
http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/2259/from-russia-with-love-vs.-on-her-majestys-secret-service/p1
http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/4395/skyfall-vs.-casino-royale-thunderball-vs.-from-russia-with-love/p1

Note please how similar they were to one another (and to this one).

So, I would like to suggest we at least use one thread that almost covers it and expand on it. I'll even add a poll. The result can be found here:
http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/121/frwl-vs-ohmss-22-june-2013-edit-vs-cr-vs-sf/p3

I hope the examples above make it perfectly clear that this thread really isn't anything new and I furthermore hope that everyone can agree with the suggestion.