The What if thread...What if Kathryn Bigelow had directed Craig in 2006 CR?

1747576777880»

Comments

  • LeonardPineLeonardPine The Bar on the Beach
    Posts: 4,334
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.
  • Posts: 8,149
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.

    I do think Kleinman can do something fresh and new, like he did with CR! I remember being a bit disappointed with Binder when he didn't come up with fresh ideas for Daltons debut ( though I still like parts of it!)
  • LeonardPineLeonardPine The Bar on the Beach
    Posts: 4,334
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.

    I do think Kleinman can do something fresh and new, like he did with CR! I remember being a bit disappointed with Binder when he didn't come up with fresh ideas for Daltons debut ( though I still like parts of it!)

    Yep, Binder was way past his best by the time Dalton came along. Daylights should have had someone new. I remember how impressive and fresh the GE titles seemed at the time.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 17,977
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.

    I do think Kleinman can do something fresh and new, like he did with CR! I remember being a bit disappointed with Binder when he didn't come up with fresh ideas for Daltons debut ( though I still like parts of it!)

    Yep, Binder was way past his best by the time Dalton came along. Daylights should have had someone new. I remember how impressive and fresh the GE titles seemed at the time.

    Totally agree, Binder's last two are a bit sad really, with a gun firing into a puddle and laying two gambling chips onto a casino table so it says '007'. Oh dear.
    If Kleinman does decide he's done, then NTTD was far from a bad way to end it, full of lovely stuff- I loved the guns DNA helix: it was nicely funny! I think CR and Skyfall are possibly his best, although obviously GoldenEye was great and still looks fantastic today.
  • Posts: 8,149
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.

    I do think Kleinman can do something fresh and new, like he did with CR! I remember being a bit disappointed with Binder when he didn't come up with fresh ideas for Daltons debut ( though I still like parts of it!)

    Yep, Binder was way past his best by the time Dalton came along. Daylights should have had someone new. I remember how impressive and fresh the GE titles seemed at the time.

    Yeh, you're probably right mate, though I still love all his work! GE titles were the only good thing abut that film! And I really loved what MK12 did on QOS. There are some great titles designers out there. I particularly liked the ones for Finchers 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo'
  • echoecho 007 in New York
    edited April 16 Posts: 6,684
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    YKMN certainly screams “Dad Rock”, the only way that could have been topped is if they hire another aging rock act like Muse.

    LOL. I never thought it that way, but you're right.

    The one thing I *still* miss about Binder is his insistence that the title appear at the same time the song mentions the title. (He did this for FYEO, if I recall correctly.)

    The songs these days take forever getting to the title!

  • Posts: 8,149
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    Not this enthusiast! Top 10 Bond movie for me! And I would take Jack Whites theme over Adeles dreary dirge any day of the week!

    Top ten for me as well mate! And above SF.. !

    I must admit, i used to detest the Jack White theme. But it has seriously grown on me over the years.

    I like all of the Craig era songs. 'You Know My Name' obviously being the Daddy!!!

    Oh yes, YKMN blew me away when I heard it first, and coupled by Kleinmans stunning title sequence made it even better! I'm in two minds about Kleinman returning, thoughI love his work (the ONLY good thing about the Brossa era!) I think I would like to see someone new give it a go!

    My brother's mate works with Kleinman so i'm kind of biased for him to continue!

    But you're right, i think some new blood is needed across the board for this new era.

    I do think Kleinman can do something fresh and new, like he did with CR! I remember being a bit disappointed with Binder when he didn't come up with fresh ideas for Daltons debut ( though I still like parts of it!)

    Yep, Binder was way past his best by the time Dalton came along. Daylights should have had someone new. I remember how impressive and fresh the GE titles seemed at the time.

    I think there were calls for Binder to be replaced by other production members , but I think it was Cubby who insisted he stay on! Maybe not one of Cubbys best decisions!!
  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,778
    We seem to have drifted off topic ever so slightly. Does anyone have something to share about the writing of QOS and whether it might have changed the script if they were dealing with the writers strike. Otherwise I will think of a new 'what if" to pose.

  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 17,977
    The weird thing is that Some Kind of Hero says that Paul Haggis had written two drafts with some polishes with a week to go to the writers' strike, but the version of the script the book talks about is Haggis' Sleep of the Dead which involves Vesper's child in an orphanage, which is clearly not where the finished script went.

    It's hard to say where more time on the script would have ended up; I guess with a more fleshed-out script, but I don't think the script is actually all that bad. It's full of themes and has something to say; I guess maybe the problem is it doesn't really feel like it moves Bond's story on that much and feels like more of a coda to CR than a full sequel. I guess that's something would could have been addressed a bit more perhaps.
  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    Posts: 14,394
    2006 CR
    2008 QOS
    2010 POAL
    2012 RS
    2014 THR
    2016 SF
    2018 SP
    2020 NTTD
  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,778
    Dang @RichardTheBruce one does wonder if that would have played out. Crazy to see and think of the drop off in the amount of films.
  • VenutiusVenutius Yorkshire
    edited April 17 Posts: 3,274
    Could QOS actually be any better? Well, that wonderful plane scene could be a bit longer. Oho, etc!
    Yes, Haggis's time was spent mainly on the Sleep of the Dead script. EON accepted the script and then rang him the next day and said that they weren't going ahead with it. Marc Forster said he thought BB and MGW had second thoughts because they didn't like the ending where Bond left Vesper's daughter in a Romanian orphanage and walked away as if it was job done.
    Haggis said that the rejection left him barely three months to write a new script. What Haggis delivered to EON literally an hour or two before the start of the writers' strike was a first draft - or, at least, the first draft that'd been presented to EON. Compare that to the months that were spent on SP and the multiple drafts that it went through. I saw some comment once which claimed that parts of Haggis's QOS script were little more than an outline. That might be true, as the guy who played Slate said that the script for the hotel fight between him and Bond read simply 'A fight ensues' and that what we see on screen was worked out on the set.
    So, if the writer's strike hadn't happened, there'd've been several more drafts of the script and not much winging it. Would it have improved the film? Maybe. Would I take the risk of that and swap the QOS we did get? No. I love QOS. I may have said that once or twice before...
  • edited April 17 Posts: 15,595
    2006 CR
    2008 QOS
    2010 POAL
    2012 RS
    2014 THR
    2016 SF
    2018 SP
    2020 NTTD

    As much as I wanted this to be true, I think it's an overtly optimistic hypothesis. Maybe, maybe, maybe we would have had one more film between QOS and SF.

    But hey, there's certainly some space between QOS and SF to write graphic novels depicting Bond's adventures, say POAL, RS and THR.
  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    Posts: 14,394
    Yeah I'm reminded the producers' original plan was to release QOS May 2008, at the time they obviously wanted to strike while the iron was hot.

    Then the writers' strike and other developments affected schedules for QOS and all the following films really.

  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,778
    Someone espoused on Bond and Friends podcast that QOS taught Barbara and Michael to no longer adhere to the every 2 years and wait till the script was ready to be shot.

    Course this meant we had 3 films in the next 13 years. Wow I certainly don't wish Amazon to rush things but I would love to see a more regular cadence return to the films going forward.
  • MaxCasinoMaxCasino United States
    Posts: 5,005
    Ludovico wrote: »
    2006 CR
    2008 QOS
    2010 POAL
    2012 RS
    2014 THR
    2016 SF
    2018 SP
    2020 NTTD

    As much as I wanted this to be true, I think it's an overtly optimistic hypothesis. Maybe, maybe, maybe we would have had one more film between QOS and SF.

    But hey, there's certainly some space between QOS and SF to write graphic novels depicting Bond's adventures, say POAL, RS and THR.

    I actually consider the Bloodstone and Goldeneye Reloaded video games as adventures in the QOS and SF gap. I know that 007 Legends tried to fill it out as well. Thankfully, most people don't take that game as canon. But yes, @Ludovico I would love some books or graphic novels during that gap, there is some great storytelling potential.

    As for QOS and the writer's strike, I think that EON kept getting cold feet at a lot of the story ideas, throwing them out, needlessly. Within that short production time, they should have known better. The writer's strike just came around at the worst time for EON and QOS.
  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    Posts: 14,394
    Bloodstone. I'm not a gamer. Could make a decent novelization.
  • QBranchQBranch Always have an escape plan. Mine is watching James Bond films.
    Posts: 15,045
    Definitely the anomaly that is Blood Stone (no Blofeld/SPECTRE) should've be novelized or at least the story beats built upon for a series of Craig-era comics - that would be very cool. I don't count GE10 or 007L as canon, and although the former is a decent re-imagining the less said about these two the better.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 17,977
    I like Blood Stone a lot, I think they got the tone just right for a Craig adventure.
  • NoTimeToLiveNoTimeToLive Jamaica
    edited April 18 Posts: 147
    There's no way to fit 007 Legends into the Craig era as it's set between QoS and SF, but Bond and Blofeld only meet for the first time in SP.
    Besides, had Blofeld killed Bond's wife he would definitely mention that during his "author of all your pain" speech.

    Bloodstone, I could see that fit into the series; we're never told the identity of the big bad-could easily be Blofeld.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 17,977
    Bloodstone, I could see that fit into the series; we're never told the identity of the big bad-could easily be Blofeld.

    I forgot it ends like that, yes that fits rather neatly.
  • Posts: 5,164
    Bloodstone's not a game I've played myself, but I know people who have and have a rough idea of what's in it. From memory it seemed to involve Bond hopping from villain to villain without much of a main baddie. It also didn't really have gadgets (or at least nothing like the typical armed Aston Martin) which apparently made driving levels a bit limiting.
  • Last_Rat_StandingLast_Rat_Standing Long Neck Ice Cold Beer Never Broke My Heart
    Posts: 4,699
    Well you had Pomerov and Rak as the villians with Nicole ending up being bad as well but possibly blackmailed by SPECTRE similar to Vesper. It definitely fit the go between QoS and SF
  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,778
    Over the years there has been chatter about getting a female director to direct a Bond picture.

    Many fans have long championed Kathryn Bigelow—the first woman to win the Oscar for Best Director—for the 007 reins. In 2004, then Sony chief Amy Pascal publicly urged Bigelow to take on a Bond movie, citing her action chops from Point Break and Strange Days—yet Eon never pursued it seriously.

    Now that Pascal is in creative charge might we see a female direct Bond?

    For a second, lets think about Kathryn Bigelow directing Daniel Craig in CR in 2006? How might the film look and feel different?

    Imagine: A Zero Dark Thirty-infused Bond, with Bigelow’s documentary grit, a tense, claustrophobic labyrinth and the emotional stakes of a Vesper-style tragedy but grounded in real-world geopolitics?

    What if Kathryn Bigelow directed CR in 2006?
  • AnotherZorinStoogeAnotherZorinStooge Bramhall (Irish)
    Posts: 290
    thedove wrote: »
    Over the years there has been chatter about getting a female director to direct a Bond picture.

    Many fans have long championed Kathryn Bigelow—the first woman to win the Oscar for Best Director—for the 007 reins. In 2004, then Sony chief Amy Pascal publicly urged Bigelow to take on a Bond movie, citing her action chops from Point Break and Strange Days—yet Eon never pursued it seriously.

    Now that Pascal is in creative charge might we see a female direct Bond?

    For a second, lets think about Kathryn Bigelow directing Daniel Craig in CR in 2006? How might the film look and feel different?

    Imagine: A Zero Dark Thirty-infused Bond, with Bigelow’s documentary grit, a tense, claustrophobic labyrinth and the emotional stakes of a Vesper-style tragedy but grounded in real-world geopolitics?

    What if Kathryn Bigelow directed CR in 2006?

    If Kathryn Bigelow directed CR, Craig would have a wicked noughties fringe.
  • SeveSeve The island of Lemoy
    edited 10:54am Posts: 519
    thedove wrote: »
    What if Kathryn Bigelow directed CR in 2006?

    M - "Do you think that taxpayers would like it Bond, if they knew that they were paying a secret agent to surf and pick up girls?"
    James Bond - "Babes."
    M - "I beg your pardon?"
    James Bond - "The correct term is Babes, Ma'm."
    M - "You know nothing. In fact, you know less than nothing. If you knew that you knew nothing, then that would be something, but you don't."
    James Bond - "I caught my first tube today, Ma'm"

    James Bond [shouts from the shore] - "The name's Bond, James Bond!"
    Solange [paddling away] - "Who cares!"

    Rene Mathis - "22 years. Man, Royale-les-Eaux has changed a lot during that time. The air got dirty and the sex got clean."
    Felix Leiter - "I'm so hungry I could eat the ass end out of a dead rhino,"
    Mathis - "Last time you had that feeling, I had to kill a guy, and I hate that... It looks bad on my report."
    Leiter - "I've been on the job for over 20 years, and I fail to see what surfing has got to do with funding international terrorism. And on top of that, they got me babysitting some quarterback punk, named Johnny English or something"
    Rene Mathis - "Monsieur Leiter... meet your new partner."
    Leiter - "What?"
    James Bond - "The names Punk, Quarterback Punk."

    Le Chiffre - "Fear causes hesitation, and hesitation will cause your worst fears to come true."
    James Bond - "You crossed the line. People trusted you and they died. You gotta' go down."
    LeChiffre - "I know James. I know you want me so bad it's like acid in your mouth. But, not this time"
    James Bond - "You got a death wish. You want to ride to glory, fine. But, don't take Vesper with you. I'm begging you. Tell me where she is, and I walk away."

    Le Chiffre - "It's basic dog psychology, if you scare them and get them peeing down their leg, they submit. But if you project weakness, that promotes violence, and that's how people get hurt."
    Valenka - "Peace, through superior firepower."
    James Bond - "Okay. I get it. This is where you tell me that locals rule, and that Limey snobs like me shouldn't be surfing the break, right?"
    Le Chiffre [smiling] - "Nope."
    Valenka - "That would be a waste of time..."
    Le Chiffre - "We're just gonna whip your private parts!"

    James Bond - "You're cold because all of the blood is running out of your body, Mr White. You're gonna be dead soon. I hope it was worth it."

    50666004c8ad291fa072962fb1e6db53.jpg


  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    edited 2:22pm Posts: 14,394
    Bond wears his Royal Navy uniform.
    Bond surfs!
    Bond exits an aircraft at altitude (without a parachute!).
    Bond befriends a beautiful and capable female US police officer with a heart of gold experiencing career challenges.
    Bond foils cheating at the Daytona Racetrack in Florida.
    Bond weathers the dangers of Detroit, Michigan.
    A submarine.
    Virtual reality leads to murder plus virtual office romance at MI6 that Bond must pursue. Virtually.
    Bond is sent to shut down a group of former Special Forces operatives, ends up befriending them to work against still another threat.
    Vampirism.
    Plus some stuff happens at a casino.

  • QBranchQBranch Always have an escape plan. Mine is watching James Bond films.
    Posts: 15,045
    Hmm, what would be different? Barbara sees Kathryn talking to Daniel and gets a bit jelly, coming to the shocking realization that she's fallen in love with him.
  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    edited 4:35pm Posts: 14,394
    After many fine actors in the role, Keanu Reeves reestablishes the Felix Leiter role as a beloved character for the ages admired by all with sympathies going to the Texan's missing limbs and dead dog. Spawning its own compelling spinoff action franchise.

Sign In or Register to comment.