Who could've been Bond?

13»

Comments

  • Posts: 16,017
    He appears to be locked in to a neverending loop of Harlan Cobben adaptations on Netflix

    An actor's idea of Hell, probably.
  • Posts: 5,788
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.
  • Posts: 16,017
    007HallY wrote: »
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.

    I don't see it for Armitage either, to be honest. That said I always thought that he's had so far a smaller career than he could have had.
  • edited August 7 Posts: 5,788
    Ludovico wrote: »
    007HallY wrote: »
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.

    I don't see it for Armitage either, to be honest. That said I always thought that he's had so far a smaller career than he could have had.

    I suppose most actors won’t have those A-List careers. He’s making money at any rate. He’s successful compared to most actors.

    But even taking a bigger actor like Michael Fassbender I never believed he had that same charisma to break through to Bond (I acknowledge he never really had the chance incidentally, but despite being a good character actor I never thought he had what it took to do Bond, and his attempts to lead bigger blockbusters never quite worked - in part for reasons slightly beyond his control).
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    edited August 7 Posts: 18,848
    007HallY wrote: »
    Ludovico wrote: »
    007HallY wrote: »
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.

    I don't see it for Armitage either, to be honest. That said I always thought that he's had so far a smaller career than he could have had.

    I suppose most actors won’t have those A-List careers. He’s making money at any rate. He’s successful compared to most actors.

    But even taking a bigger actor like Michael Fassbender I never believed he had that same charisma to break through to Bond (I acknowledge he never really had the chance incidentally, but despite being a good character actor I never thought he had what it took to do Bond, and his attempts to lead bigger blockbusters never quite worked - in part for reasons slightly beyond his control).

    To be fair you could probably say the same of most actors who actually did play Bond, outside of the Bond films themselves that is, and Fassbender has arguably had a bigger career than many of them. I think he'd have been able to do a very decent job, I don't think he was a massive missed opportunity or anything, but I think it was in his wheelhouse. Unlike, as you say, Turner or Armitage (both Hobbits, incidentally!) who I don't think would have made the switch to the big screen.
  • Posts: 5,788
    mtm wrote: »
    007HallY wrote: »
    Ludovico wrote: »
    007HallY wrote: »
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.

    I don't see it for Armitage either, to be honest. That said I always thought that he's had so far a smaller career than he could have had.

    I suppose most actors won’t have those A-List careers. He’s making money at any rate. He’s successful compared to most actors.

    But even taking a bigger actor like Michael Fassbender I never believed he had that same charisma to break through to Bond (I acknowledge he never really had the chance incidentally, but despite being a good character actor I never thought he had what it took to do Bond, and his attempts to lead bigger blockbusters never quite worked - in part for reasons slightly beyond his control).

    To be fair you could probably say the same of most actors who actually did play Bond, outside of the Bond films themselves that is, and Fassbender has arguably had a bigger career than many of them. I think he'd have been able to do a very decent job, I don't think he was a massive missed opportunity or anything, but I think it was in his wheelhouse. Unlike, as you say, Turner or Armitage (both Hobbits, incidentally!) who I don't think would have made the switch to the big screen.

    I suppose. I think his sexual assault allegations (regardless of how much they amount to/are truthful) would have come back up more to haunt him with that lead a role. And I agree he wouldn’t have exactly been an upgrade from Craig. And ultimately he never would have had that opportunity.
  • edited August 7 Posts: 186
    I would have liked to have seen Jason Isaacs' take on Bond.
    He was unlucky (if he had wanted it) as he was likely too young when Brosnan got it and then a bit too old when Craig got it. Sometimes when an actor has been born has ruled them out.
  • Posts: 16,017
    007HallY wrote: »
    Ludovico wrote: »
    007HallY wrote: »
    My somewhat controversial opinions are that neither Turner nor Armitage had the charisma/swagger to play Bond despite being good actors and looking the part to some extent.

    I don't see it for Armitage either, to be honest. That said I always thought that he's had so far a smaller career than he could have had.

    I suppose most actors won’t have those A-List careers. He’s making money at any rate. He’s successful compared to most actors.

    But even taking a bigger actor like Michael Fassbender I never believed he had that same charisma to break through to Bond (I acknowledge he never really had the chance incidentally, but despite being a good character actor I never thought he had what it took to do Bond, and his attempts to lead bigger blockbusters never quite worked - in part for reasons slightly beyond his control).

    True, but I always thought he seemed to be heading for something bigger, a bit like Eric Bana.
  • MSL49MSL49 Finland
    Posts: 456
    Sam Neill impressed many in his screentest.
  • Posts: 2,330
    I still think Michael Fassbender would've been a great James Bond, if Craig had indeed quit after Spectre and they rebooted in 2017/2018. We could've been three films into his run by now (2017, 2019 and 2023) etc....
  • MSL49MSL49 Finland
    Posts: 456
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.
  • peterpeter Toronto
    Posts: 9,762
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.
  • DragonpolDragonpol https://thebondologistblog.blogspot.com
    Posts: 18,879
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.
  • peterpeter Toronto
    Posts: 9,762
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.

    Well done, @Dragonpol , 😂…you know how to hit the funny-bone 😂!
  • DragonpolDragonpol https://thebondologistblog.blogspot.com
    Posts: 18,879
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.

    Well done, @Dragonpol , 😂…you know how to hit the funny-bone 😂!

    Thanks @peter. I just can't help myself sometimes! :))
  • peterpeter Toronto
    Posts: 9,762
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.

    Well done, @Dragonpol , 😂…you know how to hit the funny-bone 😂!

    Thanks @peter. I just can't help myself sometimes! :))

    Please never stop— the chuckle has high value and it didn’t cost anyone a thing, lol!
  • DragonpolDragonpol https://thebondologistblog.blogspot.com
    Posts: 18,879
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.

    Well done, @Dragonpol , 😂…you know how to hit the funny-bone 😂!

    Thanks @peter. I just can't help myself sometimes! :))

    Please never stop— the chuckle has high value and it didn’t cost anyone a thing, lol!

    Yes, I'll keep going. I don't know why other way! Laughter is good medicine.
  • MSL49MSL49 Finland
    Posts: 456
    I think we are already mentioned actors who could have been Bond.
  • peterpeter Toronto
    Posts: 9,762
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    Dragonpol wrote: »
    peter wrote: »
    MSL49 wrote: »
    I would have pick Dominic West over Craig in 2005.

    Then thank God you weren't one of the producers.

    It could've all went West very quickly.

    Well done, @Dragonpol , 😂…you know how to hit the funny-bone 😂!

    Thanks @peter. I just can't help myself sometimes! :))

    Please never stop— the chuckle has high value and it didn’t cost anyone a thing, lol!

    Yes, I'll keep going. I don't know why other way! Laughter is good medicine.

    No doubt about that.
  • MSL49MSL49 Finland
    Posts: 456
    Sean Bean was he handsome enough to play Bond?
  • cwl007cwl007 England
    Posts: 621
    I have just posted something similar to this on the 'next Bond' thread, completely forgetting this one existed...
    Terence Stamp would have made a brilliant Bond. Had he stepped in to replace Connery in '69, wow. Imagine OHMSS exactly as was but with him in the role. Plus a gritty revenge follow up!
  • talos7talos7 New Orleans
    Posts: 8,567
    cwl007 wrote: »
    I have just posted something similar to this on the 'next Bond' thread, completely forgetting this one existed...
    Terence Stamp would have made a brilliant Bond. Had he stepped in to replace Connery in '69, wow. Imagine OHMSS exactly as was but with him in the role. Plus a gritty revenge follow up!

    I can also picture him as a great adversary; Scaramanga, Hugo Drax, Elliot Carver , he would have been excellent as any of them …

  • cwl007cwl007 England
    Posts: 621
    Agreed. His General Zod is unbeatable , a Bond baddie in that vain would have been great.
  • Posts: 5,788
    talos7 wrote: »
    cwl007 wrote: »
    I have just posted something similar to this on the 'next Bond' thread, completely forgetting this one existed...
    Terence Stamp would have made a brilliant Bond. Had he stepped in to replace Connery in '69, wow. Imagine OHMSS exactly as was but with him in the role. Plus a gritty revenge follow up!

    I can also picture him as a great adversary; Scaramanga, Hugo Drax, Elliot Carver , he would have been excellent as any of them …

    I can too, probably more so than him being Bond, but he was a striking/good looking guy, especially in that late 60s/early 70s period. Apparently he frightened Harry Saltzman with his suggestions for what he'd do with the role when approached about it! He was probably not even 30 then and may not have been the best fit for it. But I do wish he would have gotten the opportunity to play a villain, even later on.

    Guy had a great career though. One of those really distinctive British actors.
  • edited August 18 Posts: 16,017
    cwl007 wrote: »
    Agreed. His General Zod is unbeatable , a Bond baddie in that vain would have been great.

    I don't think any cinematic Superman villain got it right since Terence Stamp. Oh and he was criminally underused as an ineffective goodie in The Phantom Menace.
  • Stamp did manage to transcend a truly terrible costume to give Zod some menace and charisma.
  • MSL49MSL49 Finland
    Posts: 456
    Stamp had the looks and the talent.
Sign In or Register to comment.