Would you rather watch DAF (64%) OR SP (63%) Rotten Tomato Ranking battles!

1179180181182183185»

Comments

  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    Posts: 14,433
    SP. And I have A LOT of reasons to watch DAF again.

  • CommanderRossCommanderRoss The bottom of a pitch lake in Eastern Trinidad, place called La Brea
    Posts: 8,706
    Ludovico wrote: »
    SP, without hesitation.

    You might as well ask me if I'd rather watch Eyes Wide Shut or Porky's Revenge.

    Considering I haven't seen eyes wide shut, I do wonder which of these two you compare to Porky's revenge (not that I remember much of that film, saw it years ago when drunk, which was iirc the way to see it).

    For me DAF is so utterly boring, with so many random mistakes, I can't get into the film. It also detracts from Wint and Kidd whom could have been quite menacing like in the novel, but end up being oofs. Obviously, plenty is a bit of a redeeming factor, and she does describe the film perfectly (you choose between 'youre a wonderful guy, a bit weird, but wonderful' or ' is this a perverts' convention or something's), but it's not enough to keep me watching the full film.
    SP had the right idea, executed badly. Blofeld trying to get on Bond's nerves is fair game, but trying to do it through a family angle is just plain stupid considering we've been conditioned for 60 years that Bond in fact has no family. Why would he start caring now? The backtracking through previous films and adding quantum to it (why not leave it a separate entity) was also just wrong. That's how you create plotholes, not how you cover them. Other than that the story holds up a bit, Madeleine is interesting, White even more so and the locales are better than the sleazy part of last Vegas (I know, it's as good as all of it). The gliding plane beeping rubbish again though. Going for the same one-way story-suits-goal writing rather than having it develop naturally. But I still prefer it over the moon buggy chase. Winks to conspiracy theories shouldn't encompass entire sets.
  • Posts: 15,692
    Seve wrote: »
    SP easily

    There are just too many things about DAF that I absolutely loath, and it will probably always remain at the very bottom of my personal Bond movie ranking.

    However we'll see what Amazon can come up with...

    CKrVjWfWsAAPRhl.jpg

    Like I said, it's comparing Eyes Wide Shut to Porky's Revenge.
  • Posts: 8,183
    Dwayne wrote: »
    @thedove : Based on those RT ratings, there is clearly bad news for Brosnan fans ahead!

    DAF or SP?
    Neither really. But in the spirit of this thread I would take DAF. SP is a better film but DAF has a great John Barry score and ......
    s-l1200.jpg

    Ah, but SPECTREs got Monica!!🥰
Sign In or Register to comment.