Is Tiffany Case Fleming's Best Female Character?

edited January 2017 in Literary 007 Posts: 2,904
I recently contributed an article to Artistic Licence Renewed arguing that Tiffany Case is Fleming's best female character. I won't reprint the whole thing here, but I will summarize my main reasons.

First, she's funny and tough. There's more humor in Tiffany's wisecracks than there is in the first three Bond books put together. She's happy to talk back to Bond and she brings out his latent humor too, as in their long discussion about love on the Queen Elizabeth. "So you're one of those old-fashioned men who like sleeping with women. Why haven't you ever married?" she asks. Bond says his ideal wife would be "Somebody who can make Sauce Béarnaise as well as love," and Tiffany says "Holy mackerel! Just any old dumb hag who can cook and lie on her back?" Later on she sends to Bond's cabin a bowl of sauce and a note from the chef saying: "This Sauce Béarnaise has been created by Miss T. Case without my assistance."

Second, Tiffany has a complex character, shaped by inner conflict. She is a tough, independent operator but also has a suppressed vulnerability. In her first meeting with Bond, she's mostly cold and scornful ("Do you mind if I smoke?" Bond asks. "If that's the way you want to die" she responds), but after he leaves she wonders "about the man who had suddenly, out of the blue, found his way into her life. God, she thought to herself with sudden angry despair, another damn crook. Couldn't she ever get away from them?" Because of a traumatic past, she is distrustful of men and afraid of being hurt. There is a poignance in seeing her inner struggle when she begins falling for Bond--we know Bond is not the type who would hurt her, but she can't be sure. This is demonstrated after their dinner in New York, when he takes her back to her hotel:
Then she turned in the entrance and faced him.
"Listen, you Bond person..."
It had started as the beginning of an angry speech, but then she paused and looked straight into his eyes, and Bond saw that her eyelashes were wet. And suddenly she had flung an arm round his neck and her face was against his and she was saying "Look after yourself, James. I don't want to lose you." And then she pulled his face against hers and kissed him once, hard and long on the lips, with a fierce tenderness that was almost without sex.
But, as Bond's arms went round her and he started to return her kiss, she suddenly stiffened and fought her way free, and the moment was over.
With her hand on the knob of the open door, she turned and looked at him, and the sultry glow was back in her eyes.
"Now get away from me," she said fiercely, and slammed the door and locked it.

Bond has to prove himself to Tiffany, something he's never been called upon to do before. He realizes he must be more than a lover; his presence must also be be therapeutic. Occasionally he makes mistakes and upsets her by bringing up her relations with the mob, but he perseveres until they end the book on a note of happiness.

By contrast, Fleming's other female characters are less vivid:

* Vesper is one-dimensional, and only comes alive in the last quarter of the novel, when her desperation makes itself known.

* Solitaire is perhaps the most cardboard of Fleming's heroines. She begins as a damsel in distress and doesn't progress much beyond that.

* Gala Brand is more interesting--she's not impressed with Bond, being a true professional--but we don't see much of her character beyond her patriotism.

* Tatiana Romanova is a better character--we spend a couple of chapters looking at the world through her eyes and get a sense of her ordinariness and sense of vulnerability--but her personality isn't unique.

* Honeychile Ryder is a very good heroine, a child of nature whose innocence and determination come across vividly. She does however go through a "sex kitten" phase during her captivity in the mink-lined prison.

* Pussy Galore inherits Tiffany's gift for wisecracks, but doesn't appear long enough to become anything more than a lesbian caricature of Mae West. Tilly Masterton is better drawn, but Fleming's contempt for her limits her development.

* Domino is one of Fleming's very best heroines--fiery, wilful and vengeful (as we see in her destruction of Largo and "to hell with you" attitude) but also with a contemplative, wistful side (as we see in her long story about the Players cigarettes sailor).

* Vivienne Michel might possibly outrank Tiffany as Fleming's best heroine, but she has unfair advantage--she gets to narrate an entire book about herself! No wonder we get to know her character--fanciful, plucky, and a bit similar to Ian Fleming's to be honest, so well.

* Tracy di Vicenzo is basically a rewrite of Tiffany--a sensitive, depressive soul with a sad backstory and a hot-and-cold temperament--but she becomes less interesting after being cured by the psychiatrists.

* Kissy Suzuki is another of Fleming's best heroines: proud (witness her disgust with Hollywood racism), independent, and willing to take what she wants. Her keeping the amnesiac Bond might seem selfish, but can anyone deny that she gave him a good life?

* Mary Goodnight is sadly almost bereft of character--she's resourceful and a little bashful, and that's about all one can say about her.

But enough of my gabbing--who do you think Fleming's best female character is? Do my assessments do justice to your favorites? Do tell! And if you wish to comment on the article, please feel free.

Comments

  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 23,843
    Every time I read the books, she's the one girl I fall in love with, even if her cinematic version is one of my least favourite of all the Bond girls.
  • Posts: 2,904
    I agree Darth. The cinematic Tiffany is a travesty of the original. No real inner conflict and she devolves into a bimbo by the end--the curse of the Bond girls in the Hamilton/Mankiewicz films.
  • 007InVT007InVT Classified
    Posts: 893
    One of my favourites is Mary Ann Russell. Saves Bond's bacon and has some sass. I also like Judy Havelock in FYEO for taking matters into her own hands, much to Bond's chagrin!

    But Tiffany, Tracy and Domino are the best.
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 23,843
    Terrible, isn't it, @Revelator? I mean, even Goodnight, in the books, sounds like a sweet, caring, worthy-to-fight-for girl. I might marry her. Her cinematic counterpart, by contrast, is a generic sex doll, a brainless pair of breasts with absolutely no story and an unbelievable resistance to Bond's attempt at a romantic evening.

    Solitaire was never a strong character in the book in my opinion, but her film version worked big time for me. Might have something to do with Jane being unbelievably beautiful.

    But Tiffany is the worst case - no pun intended. The book lends her depth, emotional weight and a nice story arc. I can believe that Bond would want to marry her. I'm genuinely sad when in the next book we learn that things didn't work out between them. I'm always hoping for the best, even if I know how things go. But the film threw us a joke of a Bond girl, wrapped up in a poor performance. I mean, I keep hearing how great Jill St. John is supposed to be but I ain't seeing it. She wasn't good in the first two episodes of Batman The Television Series in 1966 and she was even worse here. Her line delivery is like fingernails on a chalkboard. Plus, I don't think she's beautiful or sexy, but of course that comes down to taste. The red hair? Never worked for me. Her overall charm, fairly unmemorable if you ask me. She's clearly not on the same level as Ursula Andress, Diana Rigg, Daniela Binachi, ...
  • edited January 2017 Posts: 2,904
    * I forgot about the heroines of the short stories, but they are indeed strong stuff--even the deceptively meek Liz Krest!

    * Interesting point--movie Solitaire might indeed be superior to the literary one. Jane Seymour did a good job conveying the character's innocence and mysticism...to the point where you feel like Bond was an utter cad in cheating her out of her virginity and into bed.

    * Jill St. John was definitely miscast, despite having some chemistry with Connery. She was brassy, but was given nothing beyond that to play, aside from ditziness. The producers should have gone with an extremely talented actress like Tuesday Weld, who was adept at alternating between neurosis and sensuality, but by the early 70s they just wanted T&A. After OHMSS under-performed there was a deliberate effort for several years to exclude anything resembling genuine emotion and characterization from the Bond films.
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    DarthDimi wrote: »
    Every time I read the books, she's the one girl I fall in love with, even if her cinematic version is one of my least favourite of all the Bond girls.

    Domino is my favorite Bond girl in both novel and film.
  • ThunderpussyThunderpussy My Secret Lair
    Posts: 13,384
    It's funny in DAF, Fleming mentions Bond
    Thinking of retiring to Japan and used the
    Term " We have all the time in the world "
  • Agent_99Agent_99 enjoys a spirited ride as much as the next girl
    Posts: 3,148
    Gala Brand. She has to deal with something way out of the ordinary scope of her job, and she does it well. Then, for an encore, she ruins Bond's big seduction plans.

    Honourable mention goes to Vivienne Michel, because she's one of the reasons I got a scooter as soon as I was old enough.
Sign In or Register to comment.