Avatar

Reporting For Duty

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

ProfJoeButcher

About

Username
ProfJoeButcher
Location
Bless your heart
Joined
Visits
12,816
Last Active
Roles
Member
Location
Bless your heart
Favourite Fleming Novel
Dr No
Favourite Bond Film
SPECTRE
Favourite Bond Actor
Timothy Dalton
Posts
1,732

Comments

  • Quantum_of_Tomorrow wrote: » I had the SP score at #11, it's repetitive and it's got the same cues as SF but that's always sat well with me. I understand why it ends up here but I think it suits the tone of the film in some places (like the anticl…
  • BT3366 wrote: » It will be interesting to watch where GF and other early Bonds end up in future rankings. I'd also be curious to see someone who becomes a fan from seeing NTTD or the next film following it (a decade from now for all we know) and s…
  • Quantum_of_Tomorrow wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » One so rarely hears a kind word said about Goldfinger...! /:) Well Goldfinger isn't underrated because it gets the love it deserves Yeah, I was trying to choose an ironic e…
  • One so rarely hears a kind word said about Goldfinger...! /:)
  • Back on the topic of songs we don't much like, I don't find DAD all that offensive apart from the nonsense lyric. My actual least favorite, and the only one I completely dislike, is For Your Eyes Only. It's a big fat slice of cheesy adult contemp…
  • DarthDimi wrote: » MakeshiftPython wrote: » And Madonna got the last laugh when her song was the biggest hit for Bond since AVTAK, and there wouldn’t be another until Adele threw her two cents. I bet that if Madonna had recorded herself…
  • STLCards3 wrote: » HOT TAKE ALERT! LALD's PTS was atmospheric, intriguing, and a perfect mood-setter for the oddly satisfactory supernatural tinge of the film. Bond's mysterious absence (especially while introducing a new Bond) fit perfectly w…
  • :)) I love how videos like this rope virtually all astrophysicists (and other experts) in the world into the conspiracy by virtue of their silence about the alleged problem. It makes it safer and easier to ignore, like explanations of why the Gen…
  • DarthDimi wrote: » I have wondered about the TB lyrics my whole life. Glad I'm not the only one. ;-) Which begs the question; who does Tina sing about? "I've been watching you from the shadows as a child." Is she talking about Pierce looking up…
  • Dragonpol wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » Yeah, and admittedly, Thunderball is a lot less clear than Mr Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Goldfinger, or Golden Gun! And it's probably better for it... 🤔 Yes, a song you have to think about has more m…
  • Yeah, and admittedly, Thunderball is a lot less clear than Mr Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Goldfinger, or Golden Gun! And it's probably better for it... 🤔
  • Well sure, of course everything is up to personal interpretation to some degree. The song can speak to me about Bond, Largo, Vargas, or Saddam Hussein. But if someone asks what a song is about, presumably they're not asking what it means to them sub…
  • Dragonpol wrote: » Thunderpussy wrote: » I'd Always assumed it was about Largo, " looks at the world and wants it all " I think parts of it could be seen as being about both Bond and the villain Largo depending on how the lyrics are c…
  • marc wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » It's been a while, but in the novel, doesn't Bond have a bit more reasonable hope that his message got out? In the film, it's clear to him that it didn't. Yes, Bond takes pains to hide a message to th…
  • TripAces wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » BT3366 wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » BT3366 wrote: » DarthDimi wrote: » Some have argued that if Frodo had never left the Shire, if he had just kept the ring safe, Sauron wouldn't ha…
  • STLCards3 wrote: » BT3366 wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » STLCards3 wrote: » JamesStock wrote: » GF - Predator treatment of women, Goldfinger being sucked out of the plane . How could any discussion of Goldfinger and cring…
  • BT3366 wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » BT3366 wrote: » DarthDimi wrote: » Some have argued that if Frodo had never left the Shire, if he had just kept the ring safe, Sauron wouldn't have found it, and evil would eventually have destro…
  • BT3366 wrote: » Thunderball wrote: » It seems to me that, like Ian Fleming, Guy Hamilton takes a dim view of us Americans and Felix and all the idiot, cartoony gangsters are a result of that, whereas (if his cool, aloof Felixes are any indicat…
  • BT3366 wrote: » DarthDimi wrote: » Some have argued that if Frodo had never left the Shire, if he had just kept the ring safe, Sauron wouldn't have found it, and evil would eventually have destroyed itself. There's probably always a simpler…
  • GoldenGun wrote: » Please do consider how the music is used in the film though, since some albums, like TSWLM or LTK, are not really representative of the film's score. Basically, does the film score contribute to your enjoyment of the film? Do…
  • Maybe I'm wrong and it could be made interesting, but I can't conceive of a point to any spinoff. I mean, Bond is barely a character. Bond movies are mostly about an aesthetic, I'd say. There's not all that much going on with James Bond, and even…
  • DarthDimi wrote: » Some have argued that if Frodo had never left the Shire, if he had just kept the ring safe, Sauron wouldn't have found it, and evil would eventually have destroyed itself. There's probably always a simpler solution than the c…
  • marc wrote: » JamesStock wrote: » Oooh, this one's tough. For me, QOS is probably closest to cringe-free for me. Almost the entire QoS movie is cringy, for me ;) 😅 ProfJoeButcher wrote: » I don't know if it counts as cringe, but the…
  • echo wrote: » Why does everyone hate YOLT so much? I mean, the Barry music alone should give it a point or two. In fact, I don't think I could put any Barry-scored PTS last, not even TMWTGG or AVTAK. My second-favorite is in one of my least-f…
  • I think CR is liked by people outside the Bond fan community mostly because it's not very much like a Bond film. It's generic-ness is a big part of why I have relatively little regard for it. And I've mentioned this elsewhere I'm sure, but I've n…
  • STLCards3 wrote: » JamesStock wrote: » GF - Predator treatment of women, Goldfinger being sucked out of the plane . How could any discussion of Goldfinger and cringe NOT include that abhorrent acting and dialogue at the "hoods conventi…
  • Well, Casino Royale (the 2006 one) contains virtually none of the standard EON Bond tropes, save a snippet of Bond theme and a title sequence, and it was a commercial and critical success. With nothing more than the name "James Bond", a rival produc…
  • YouveHadYourSix wrote: » ProfJoeButcher wrote: » YouveHadYourSix wrote: » Heres my ranking subject to change with each passing day. 1. Licence to Kill 2. Octopussy 3. GoldenEye 4. SPECTRE 5. On Her Majesty’s Secret Service 6. Live …
  • YouveHadYourSix wrote: » Heres my ranking subject to change with each passing day. 1. Licence to Kill 2. Octopussy 3. GoldenEye 4. SPECTRE 5. On Her Majesty’s Secret Service 6. Live and Let Die 7. Tomorrow Never Dies 8. Skyfall 9. Die A…