Rate the Various Categories - The Villains - This Week, Klaus Maria Brandauer as Maximilian Largo

1567911

Comments

  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    Posts: 6,759
    Sophie Marceau as Elektra King in The World Is Not Enough


    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 10
    2. Sadism – 9
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 8
    4. Physically Menacing – 6
    5. Dialogue – 9

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson: Renard – 2

    44/55
    80.00%

    GoldenGun's Rankings

    1. Alec Trevelyan - 92.73%
    2. Francisco Scaramanga - 89.09%
    3. Franz Sanchez - 87.27%
    4. Rosa Klebb - 87.27%
    5. Emilio Largo - 85.45%
    6. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (OHMSS) - 83.64%
    7. Auric Goldfinger - 81.81%
    8. Georgi Koskov - 81.81%
    9. Elektra King 80.00%
    10. Dr. No - 80.00%
    11. Max Zorin - 78.18%
    12. Hugo Drax - 76.36%
    13. Aristotle Kristatos - 74.55%
    14. Kamal Khan - 74.55%
    15. Mr. Big/Dr. Kananga - 74.55%
    16. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 72.73%
    17. Elliot Carver - 72.73%
    18. Karl Stromberg - 67.27%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 65.45%


    In case of a tie, my preferred choice gets the higher spot.
  • GBFGBF
    Posts: 3,195
    Sophie Marceau as Elektra King in The World Is Not Enough


    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 10
    2. Sadism – 9
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 8
    4. Physically Menacing – 6
    5. Dialogue – 9

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson: Renard – 2

    44/55
    80.00%
  • CommanderRossCommanderRoss The bottom of a pitch lake in Eastern Trinidad, place called La Brea
    Posts: 7,948
    Catching up again:

    Sean Bean as Alec Trevelyan in GoldenEye

    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 10 well, he's just perfect for the role.
    2. Sadism – 7 Not that sadistic, just a good dose of dark humour and cynisisnm
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 9 not bad, a nice incarnation of Moonraker. The book, that is.
    4. Physically Menacing – 9 Alec sure is a prprer advisary. Not by default the winner of a fight though.
    5. Dialogue – 10 Here he truly shines.

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson – Xenia - 5 she's hot and deadly. perfect combo.

    50/55
    90.91%


    Jonathan Pryce as Elliot Carver in Tomorrow Never Dies


    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 8 Good, over does it a little here and there.
    2. Sadism – 6 again also not that impressive, nothing really stands out. It's the doctor that takes the cake. Elliot doesn't seem interested.
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 6 fits the times, but is far fetched.
    4. Physically Menacing – 6 he isn't, he's got Stamper for that.
    5. Dialogue – 8 fun, for sure.
    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson – Stamper - 3 A bit one-sided.

    37/55
    67.27%

    Sophie Marceau as Elektra King...

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 8 Sexy, beautiful and smart, and yet....
    2. Sadism – 10 The way she asks Bond if he knows what happens to men when they're almost suffocating, while slowly breaking his neck....
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 7 An up to date version of GF, and hence not the strongest of stories.
    4. Physically Menacing – 4 erm, no, she has other 'qualities'.
    5. Dialogue – 8 A bit over the top, but she makes it work, which I think in itself is impressive.

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Renard -4 annoying enough to get some more points then he probably deserves, I love the fatalistic stares (i.e. when he looks at the eternal burning stones).

    41/55 = 74.55%




    Rankings %

    The Commander's Charts:


    01. Max Zorin - 90,91%
    01. Alec Travelyan - 90,91%
    03. Dr. No – 89,09%
    04. Robert Davi's Franz Sanchez - 89,09%
    05. Auric Goldfinger 85,45%
    06. Rosa Klebb - 83,64%
    06. Yaphet Kotto - 83, 64%
    08. Emilio Largo - 81,81%
    09. Louis Jourdan as Kamal Khan. 80%
    10. Telly Savalas as Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 78,18%
    11. Sophie Marceau as Elektra King - 74, 55%
    12. Michael Lonsdale as Hugo Drax - 70.91%
    12. Jeroen Krabbé's Georgi Koskov - 70.91%
    13. Julian Glover as Ari Kristatos - 69,09%
    13. Curt Jürgens as Karl Stromberg in The Spy Who Loved Me -69,09%
    15. Johnathan Price as Elliot Carver - 67,27%
    16. Christopher Lee as Francisco Scaramanga - 65,45%
    17. Charles Gray as Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 60%
    18. Donald Pleasance as Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 54,54%
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 23,449
    @royale65
    Might we move on with this thread? I'd love to get to the final couple of entries. :)
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Community Scores -

    1. Franz Sanchez – 88.68%
    2. Max Zorin – 85.19%
    3. Alec Trevelyan – 84.41%
    4. Auric Goldfinger – 82.82%
    5. Rosa Klebb – 82.25%
    6. Francisco Scaramanga – 81.13%
    7. Dr. No – 80.99%
    8. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Savalas)– 78.78%
    9. Dr. Kananga – 77.72
    10. Emilio Largo – 76.36%
    11. Kamal Khan – 76.13%
    12. Hugo Drax – 75.22%
    13. Karl Stromberg – 72.72%
    14. Elektra King – 71.59%
    15. General Georgi Koskov – 70.38%
    16. Elliot Carver – 70.12%
    17. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Gray) – 69.54%
    18. Aristotle Kristatos – 69.54%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Pleasence) – 60%

    Ask and ye shall receive @DarthDimi. 18 days later, mind. Sorry this thread has been dormant. Surgery and a lack of unlaziness from my part.
  • edited July 2019 Posts: 19,339
    Whoops !!

    I Already voted.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    edited July 2019 Posts: 4,418
    You've already done Elektra Bazza. ^ was the community scores. Very consistent @Barry007, you gave Ms. King 44 on both ratings.
  • Posts: 19,339
    royale65 wrote: »
    You've already done Elektra Bazza. ^ was the community scores. Very consistent @Barry007, you gave Ms. King 44 on both ratings.

    I just realised that and deleted the above score,silly bugger, I am.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    The OP shouldn't have left it so long between posts.
  • Posts: 19,339
    royale65 wrote: »
    The OP shouldn't have left it so long between posts.

    Definitely,i agree.
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 23,449
    Looking forward to the next in line. :)
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Gustav Graves should be here in about 2020.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Toby Stephens as Gustav Graves...

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 6 (Let down by some awful lines, but as a gross approximation of what a genocidal North Korean General thinks James Bond as….. not bad.)
    2. Sadism – 8 (Poor anger therapist)
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 6
    4. Physically Menacing – 6
    5. Dialogue – 2

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Zao – 0 (By far the worst henchman of the series. Not being hyperbolic. Can’t stand him. Awful acting. Awful character. The scene on the bridge, when Bond and Zao are being exchanged. Should be a great scene. Instead I’m facepalming over Zao. He’s walking like a Thunderbirds puppet!!!)

    28/55 = 50.90%

    Royale’s Rank of Rascality

    1. Franz Sanchez – 90.90%
    2. Auric Goldfinger – 90.90%
    3. Max Zorin – 85.45%
    4. Rosa Klebb – 83.63%
    5. Dr. No – 81.81%
    6. Francisco Scaramanga – 81.81%
    7. Dr. Kananga – 81.81%
    8. Kamal Khan – 80%
    9. Alec Trevelyan - 78.18%
    10. Emilio Largo – 76.36%
    11. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Savalas) – 74.54%
    12. Hugo Drax – 72.72%
    13. General Georgi Koskov – 72.72%
    14. Elliot Carver – 72.72%
    15. Elektra King – 70.90%
    16. Aristotle Kristatos – 70.90
    17. Karl Stromberg – 70.90%
    18. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Gray) – 67.27%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Pleasence) – 58.18
    20. Gustav Graves – 50.90%
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    edited July 2019 Posts: 23,449
    Toby Stephens as Gustav Graves...

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 5 (A decent actor overall, just not very compelling in this film.)
    2. Sadism – 5 (Moon perhaps; Graves not so much.)
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 2 (Very weak.)
    4. Physically Menacing – 7 (RoboGraves seems hard to beat;)
    5. Dialogue – 4 (A few unfortunate lines.)

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Zao - 2 (Fine... I guess.)

    25/55 = 45.45%

    DD's Ranking of evil awesomeness
    Rosa Klebb - 90.91%
    Alec Trevelyan - 87,27 %
    Dr. No – 85.45%
    Franz Sanchez - 81.82%
    Max Zorin - 78.18%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (OHMSS) - 74.55%
    Kamal Khan - 74.55%
    Carl Stromberg - 72.73%
    Elliot Carver - 72.73%
    Emilio Largo - 70.91%
    Hugo Drax - 70.91%
    Kananga - 69.09%
    Kristatos - 69.09%
    Georgi Koskov - 67.27%
    Scaramanga - 65.45%
    Goldfinger - 65.45%
    Elektra King - 63.64%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 63.64%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 60,00%
    Gustav Graves - 45.45%
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    edited July 2019 Posts: 6,759
    Toby Stephens as Gustav Graves in Die Another Day


    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 8
    2. Sadism – 7
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 4
    4. Physically Menacing – 8
    5. Dialogue – 5

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson: Zao – 2

    34/55
    61.82%

    GoldenGun's Rankings

    1. Alec Trevelyan - 92.73%
    2. Francisco Scaramanga - 89.09%
    3. Franz Sanchez - 87.27%
    4. Rosa Klebb - 87.27%
    5. Emilio Largo - 85.45%
    6. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (OHMSS) - 83.64%
    7. Auric Goldfinger - 81.81%
    8. Georgi Koskov - 81.81%
    9. Elektra King 80.00%
    10. Dr. No - 80.00%
    11. Max Zorin - 78.18%
    12. Hugo Drax - 76.36%
    13. Kamal Khan - 74.55%
    14. Aristotle Kristatos - 74.55%
    15. Mr. Big/Dr. Kananga - 74.55%
    16. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 72.73%
    17. Elliot Carver - 72.73%
    18. Karl Stromberg - 67.27%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 65.45%
    20. Gustav Graves - 61.82%

    In case of a tie, my preferred choice gets the higher spot.
  • Posts: 4,023
    Toby Stephens as Gustav Graves

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 7
    2. Sadism – 5
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 3
    4. Physically Menacing – 6
    5. Dialogue – 3

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Zao - 2

    26/55 = 47.27%

    Rankings %

    Max Zorin - 89.09
    Franz Sanchez - 89.09
    Francisco Scaramanga - 87.28
    Drax - 81.81
    Alec Trevelyan - 81.81
    Rosa Klebb - 80
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 80
    Kamal Khan - 80
    Dr No – 74.55
    Ernst Stavros Blofeld (OHMSS) - 74.55
    Kananga - 74.55
    Goldfinger - 72.72
    Koskov - 72.72
    Emilio Largo - 70.9
    Kristatos - 61.82
    Elliot Carver - 61.82
    Elektra King - 60
    Stromberg - 56.36
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 50.91
    Gustav Graves - 47.27
  • edited July 2019 Posts: 19,339
    Toby Stephens as Gustav Graves

    /10 - out of 10

    1. Actor – 6
    2. Sadism – 7
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 4
    4. Physically Menacing – 7
    5. Dialogue – 6

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Zao - 3

    33/55
    60%


    Bazza's Rankings


    Franz Sanchez - 94.54%
    Max Zorin - 87.27%
    Francisco Scaramanga - 85.45%
    Emilio Largo - 83.63%
    Savalas Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 81.81%
    Prince Kamal Khan - 80%
    Alec Trevalyan - 80%
    Rosa Klebb - 78.18%
    Hugo Drax - 76.36%
    Dr. No – 76.36%
    Auric Goldfinger - 72.72%
    Aris Kristatos - 72.72%
    Elektra King - 70.90% (It's Renard that let her down,terrible villain.)
    Karl Stromberg - 70.90%
    Elliot Carver - 69.09%
    General Georgi Koskov - 67.27%
    Gustav Graves - 60%
    Pleasance Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 52.72%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Die Another Day Update!

    Community Scores -

    1. Franz Sanchez – 88.68%
    2. Max Zorin – 85.19%
    3. Alec Trevelyan – 84.41%
    4. Auric Goldfinger – 82.82%
    5. Rosa Klebb – 82.25%
    6. Francisco Scaramanga – 81.13%
    7. Dr. No – 80.99%
    8. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Savalas)– 78.78%
    9. Dr. Kananga – 77.72
    10. Emilio Largo – 76.36%
    11. Kamal Khan – 76.13%
    12. Hugo Drax – 75.22%
    13. Karl Stromberg – 72.72%
    14. Elektra King – 71.59%
    15. General Georgi Koskov – 70.38%
    16. Elliot Carver – 70.12%
    17. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Gray) – 69.54%
    18. Aristotle Kristatos – 69.54%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Pleasence) – 60%
    20. Gustav Graves – 53.93%

  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Mads Mikkelsen as Le Chiffre...

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 9 (Great actor, great character. Full of sadism, covering a craven attitude)
    2. Sadism – 9 (Ask Bond’s balls. Minus marks for being so efficient)
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 8
    4. Physically Menacing – 8 (Great match up between the two of them)
    5. Dialogue – 9 (“Will you yield in time?” Lovely stuff)

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Kratt - 3 (The dude with the knife. Le Chiffre has a few members of his goon squad. But Kratt was the main goon, and the most memorable. Tempted to put either Dimitrios, Gettler etc. but they were on level with Le Chiffre or above him.)

    46/55 = 83.63%

    Royale’s Rank of Rascality

    1. Franz Sanchez – 90.90%
    2. Auric Goldfinger – 90.90%
    3. Max Zorin – 85.45%
    4. Rosa Klebb – 83.63%
    5. Le Chiffre – 83.63%
    6. Dr. No – 81.81%
    7. Francisco Scaramanga – 81.81%
    8. Dr. Kananga – 81.81%
    9. Kamal Khan – 80%
    10. Alec Trevelyan - 78.18%
    11. Emilio Largo – 76.36%
    12. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Savalas) – 74.54%
    13. Hugo Drax – 72.72%
    14. General Georgi Koskov – 72.72%
    15. Elliot Carver – 72.72%
    16. Elektra King – 70.90%
    17. Aristotle Kristatos – 70.90
    18. Karl Stromberg – 70.90%
    19. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Gray) – 67.27%
    20. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (Pleasence) – 58.18
    21. Gustav Graves – 50.90%
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 23,449
    Mads Mikkelsen as Le Chiffre...

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 9 (Excellent performance. Calm, convincing, ...)
    2. Sadism – 10 (We're all clear on this, right?)
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 9 (Excellent! For once, the main bad guy isn't really the main bad guy, just some middle man but enough trouble for Bond as it is. This scheme is simple but original in the Bonds.)
    4. Physically Menacing – 5 (Well we won't ever know, will we? Bond doesn't even defeat this guy in their endgame. And I applaud that change of tone.)
    5. Dialogue – 9 (One of the best Bond scripts ever, full of some of the best lines ever written for a Bond film.)

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Kratt- 3 (Nothing wrong with him. Nothing too exciting either.)

    45/55 = 81.82%

    DD's Ranking of evil awesomeness
    Rosa Klebb - 90.91%
    Alec Trevelyan - 87,27 %
    Dr. No – 85.45%
    Franz Sanchez - 81.82%
    Le Chiffre - 81.82%
    Max Zorin - 78.18%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (OHMSS) - 74.55%
    Kamal Khan - 74.55%
    Carl Stromberg - 72.73%
    Elliot Carver - 72.73%
    Emilio Largo - 70.91%
    Hugo Drax - 70.91%
    Kananga - 69.09%
    Kristatos - 69.09%
    Georgi Koskov - 67.27%
    Scaramanga - 65.45%
    Goldfinger - 65.45%
    Elektra King - 63.64%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 63.64%
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 60,00%
    Gustav Graves - 45.45%
  • edited July 2019 Posts: 19,339
    Mads Mikkelsen as Le Chiffre

    /10 - out of 10

    1. Actor – 10
    2. Sadism – 9
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 8
    4. Physically Menacing – 7
    5. Dialogue – 9

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson – Kratt - 5/5


    48/55 = 87.27%


    Bazza's Rankings


    Franz Sanchez - 94.54%
    Max Zorin - 87.27%
    Le Chiffre - 82.27%
    Francisco Scaramanga - 85.45%
    Emilio Largo - 83.63%
    Savalas Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 81.81%
    Prince Kamal Khan - 80%
    Alec Trevelyan - 80%
    Rosa Klebb - 78.18%
    Hugo Drax - 76.36%
    Dr. No – 76.36%
    Auric Goldfinger - 72.72%
    Aris Kristatos - 72.72%
    Elektra King - 70.90% (It's Renard that let her down,terrible villain.)
    Karl Stromberg - 70.90%
    Elliot Carver - 69.09%
    General Georgi Koskov - 67.27%
    Gustav Graves - 60%
    Pleasance Ernst Stavro Blofeld - 52.72%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Kratt is the nominated henchman @barryt007
  • Posts: 19,339
    royale65 wrote: »
    Kratt is the nominated henchman @barryt007

    OK,changed.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Thanks Bazza.
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    Posts: 6,759
    Mads Mikkelsen as Le Chiffre in Casino Royale


    /10 out of 10

    1. Actor – 9
    2. Sadism – 10
    3. Villain’s Scheme – 8
    4. Physically Menacing – 6
    5. Dialogue – 9

    Bonus Round!

    /5 - out of 5

    6. Henchperson: Kratt - 1

    43/55
    78.18%


    GoldenGun's Rankings

    1. Alec Trevelyan - 92.73%
    2. Francisco Scaramanga - 89.09%
    3. Franz Sanchez - 87.27%
    4. Rosa Klebb - 87.27%
    5. Emilio Largo - 85.45%
    6. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (OHMSS) - 83.64%
    7. Auric Goldfinger - 81.81%
    8. Georgi Koskov - 81.81%
    9. Elektra King 80.00%
    10. Dr. No - 80.00%
    11. Max Zorin - 78.18%
    12. Le Chiffre - 78.18%
    13. Hugo Drax - 76.36%
    14. Kamal Khan - 74.55%
    15. Aristotle Kristatos - 74.55%
    16. Mr. Big/Dr. Kananga - 74.55%
    17. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 72.73%
    18. Elliot Carver - 72.73%
    19. Karl Stromberg - 67.27%
    20. Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 65.45%
    21. Gustav Graves - 61.82%


    In case of a tie, my preferred choice gets the higher spot.
  • Posts: 4,023
    Mads Mikkelsen as Le Chiffre

    /10 - out of 10
    1. Actor – 9
    2. Sadism – 10
    3. Villain’s Scheme - 9
    4. Physically Menacing – 10
    5. Dialogue – 9

    Bonus Round!
    /5 - out of 5
    6. Henchperson – Kratt (had to google him) - 0

    47/55 = 85.45%

    Rankings %

    Max Zorin - 89.09
    Franz Sanchez - 89.09
    Francisco Scaramanga - 87.28
    Le Chiffre - 85.45
    Drax - 81.81
    Alec Trevelyan - 81.81
    Rosa Klebb - 80
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (DAF) - 80
    Kamal Khan - 80
    Dr No – 74.55
    Ernst Stavros Blofeld (OHMSS) - 74.55
    Kananga - 74.55
    Goldfinger - 72.72
    Koskov - 72.72
    Emilio Largo - 70.9
    Kristatos - 61.82
    Elliot Carver - 61.82
    Elektra King - 60
    Stromberg - 56.36
    Ernst Stavro Blofeld (YOLT) - 50.91
    Gustav Graves - 47.27
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Birdleson wrote: »
    Some interesting stats and comparisons to make when we're finished:
    -Compare our final lists with our Villains list done without going by the numbers (I posted one recently).
    -See if any of us is in exact sync with the group as a whole, or if no one, who's closest (and farthest out).

    That's the ideal scenario for each of these threads - compare our guts to the numbers.
  • Posts: 4,023
    He had lots of numbers
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    "I'm a good judge of man. You have what the Greeks call "thrausos" - numbers!"
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,418
    Any last minute votes?
Sign In or Register to comment.