Bond Movie A vs. Bond Movie B (Dr. No vs. SkyFall)
  • PrinceKamalKhanPrinceKamalKhan
    Posts: 1,744
    Moonraker. I saw it first of these two so I freely admit that may have some influence on my decision here. Nonetheless, I think it's aged the better of the two Lewis Gilbert-directed sci-fi Bond Moore flicks. I prefer John Barry's more traditionally sounding music to Marvin Hamlisch's disco score, Lois Chiles to Barbara Bach, Lonsdale's Drax to Jurgens' Stromberg. I also like how Bond meets both the leading lady and the central villain early on in the story in MR.
  • 0iker00iker0
    Posts: 396
    No doubt with this two
    The Spy Who Loved Me: my second favourite vs. Moonraker, the worst film of the series, with a stupid superstrong Jaws who can be carried out by a few people, that falls in love, and that even talks. A film where Bond goes to the space and uses laser guns. Laser guns! this is not Star Wars, even though this film was made because of the success of Star Wars.
    So yes: TSWLM
  • VolanteVolante
    Posts: 774
    TSWLM
  • haserothaserot
    Posts: 2,158
    while my feelings towards Moonraker have lightened up a bit in recent time - it's still the dumber and sillier out of the two... and i still maintain that MR is just dumbed down clone of TSWLM...

    MR might have the better score, and better villain... but overall, I feel as though the plot of TSWLM while being over the top, and far fetched - doesn't take it to the absurd levels that MR does.... also, Moore reaches the apex of his tenure as 007 in TSWLM, and brings forth his best outing in the role... Jaws is a menacing threat, and not the sideshow clown he became in MR... plus IMO, the action set pieces are far better and more memorable in TSWLM than MR..

    verdict : The Spy Who Loved Me
  • timmertimmer
    Posts: 1,137
    Two awesome Bond-films in the grand escapist design. If I must pick, I'll take MR. Bond in outerspace. Spectacular!
  • KerimKerim
    Posts: 1,596
    Moonraker for not having a disco soundtrack.
  • 007RogerMoore007RogerMoore
    Posts: 1,051
    A tough match. But MR is to good, it has the edge.
  • AussieBondAussieBond
    Posts: 182
    The Spy Who Loved Me
  • WVPoefWVPoef
    Posts: 145
    MR wins

    List of rating.
    MR - 10
    TSWLM - 13
  • commandbond007commandbond007
    Posts: 660
    TSWLM better Bond girl! plot very similar and villian is weak.......TSWLM better henchman Jaws than MR Jaws so definately TSWLM
  • identigraphidentigraph
    Posts: 662
    TSWLM, it's a better all around film and Jaws is still a decent henchman at this point.
  • BennyBenny
    Posts: 1,629
    Both these films have a strong place in my appreciation of all things Bondian. But as TSWLM started this most wonderful journey, how could I vote against it?
    Again, another tough choice. MR has many many reasons to enjoy it. Spy just edges it out though.
  • actonsteveactonsteve
    Posts: 1,324
    They are the same film film arent they?

    One is underwater, the other in outer space?

    Spy wins. It doesnt quite have the film ruining humour of MR. Its a little more toned down and witty. MR is spectacular but as soon as Jaws flaps his arms to comedy music as he plummets towards the circus tent we know what kind of film it was going to be.

    And Spy doesnt have a Mayan pyramid in the Brazilian rainforest. Schoolboy error.
  • Agent007391Agent007391
    Posts: 3,575
    TSWLM which is now 12-5, winning.
  • 4EverBonded4EverBonded
    Posts: 2,589
    Oh there is no hesitation for me: TSWLM, one of my favorites.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007
    Posts: 4,831
    Evidently MR, due to the majestic Barry soundtrack, and the most entertaining Bond performance in the franchise !! But TSWLM is also very good.
  • SirHenryLeeChaChingSirHenryLeeChaChing
    Posts: 2,329
    TSWLM easily and completely over that mockery of a Fleming novel X(

    The only thing Moonraker has going for it in comparison is a Barry soundtrack.
  • Samuel001Samuel001
    Posts: 10,182
    Moonraker.
  • Agent007391Agent007391
    Posts: 3,575
    14-7, TSWLM's favor, still.
  • thelivingroyalethelivingroyale
    Posts: 7,914
    TSWLM Brilliant film, Roger is on top form.
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi
    Posts: 5,988
    MR

    Look, TSWLM is probably the more stable film but MR, IMO, is by far the most enjoyable of these two. In the end, all I need to do is listen to the Barry score and go: yes, MR all the way! :)
  • Agent007391Agent007391
    Posts: 3,575
    15-8, TSWLM still on top.
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce
    Posts: 2,423
    MR sneaks it by just being a bit more entertaining throughout. Hard pressed to think of a boring bit of MR but TSWLM has the odd lull here and there. MR never lets up and puts every penny up on the screen at all times. Rollocking good fun. Even as a Fleming purist I have to say that its simply a fantastic romp.
  • SaintMarkSaintMark
    Posts: 2,177
    Moonraker - better women, more fun, excellent actionscenes and one of the great 007 scores.
  • QsAssistantQsAssistant
    Posts: 698
    Love both but I going with The Spy Who Loved Me. I just enjoy the story more.
  • The007SwedeThe007Swede
    Posts: 123
    The Spy Who Loved Me. For me it just feels as a superior movie overall.
  • Agent005Agent005
    Posts: 550
    The Spy Who Loved Me
  • Agent007391Agent007391
    Posts: 3,575
    21-10, still TSWLM.
  • Baltimore_007Baltimore_007
    Posts: 4,578
    No sense in voting really but I went with Moonraker, it's simply more fun and is unparalleled in the franchise for action some would say
  • SharkBaitSharkBait
    Posts: 931
    Moonraker for me. Better villain, better score, better atmosphere, has aged better...yada yada yada....
Add a Comment

Categories

In this Discussion